首页
登录
职称英语
In the grand scheme of things Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill are normal
In the grand scheme of things Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill are normal
游客
2023-12-06
46
管理
问题
In the grand scheme of things Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill are normally thought of as good guys. Between them, they came up with the ethical theory known as utilitarianism. The goal of this theory is encapsulated in Bentham’s aphorism that "the greatest happiness of the greatest number is the foundation of morals and legislation."
It all sounds fine and dandy until you start applying it to particular cases. A utilitarian, for example, might approve of the occasional torture of suspected terrorists—for the greater happiness of everyone else, you understand. That type of observation has led Daniel Bartels at Columbia University and David Pizarro at Cornell to ask what sort of people actually do have a utilitarian outlook on life. Their answers, just published in Cognition, are not comfortable.
One of the classic techniques used to measure a person’s willingness to behave in a utilitarian way is known as trolleyology.
The subject of the study is challenged with thought experiments involving a runaway railway trolley or train carriage. All involve choices, each of which leads to people’s deaths. For example: there are five railway workmen in the path of a runaway carriage. The men will surely be killed unless the subject of the experiment, a bystander in the story, does something. The subject is told he is on a bridge over the tracks. Next to him is a big, heavy stranger. The subject is informed that his own body would be too light to stop the train, but that if he pushes the stranger onto the tracks, the stranger’s large body will stop the train and save the five lives. That, unfortunately, would kill the stranger.
Dr. Bartels and Dr. Pizarro knew from previous research that around 90% of people refuse the utilitarian act of killing one individual to save five. What no one had previously inquired about, though, was the nature of the remaining 10%.
To find out, the two researchers gave 208 undergraduates a battery of trolleyological tests and measured, on a four-point scale, how utilitarian their responses were. Participants were also asked to respond to a series of statements intended to get a sense of their individual psychologies. These statements included, "I like to see fist fights", "The best way to handle people is to tell them what they want to hear", and "When you really think about it, life is not worth the effort of getting up in the morning". Each was asked to indicate, for each statement, where his views lay on a continuum that had "strongly agree" at one end and "strongly disagree" at the other. These statements, and others like them, were designed to measure, respectively, psychopathy, Machiavellianism and a person’s sense of how meaningful life is.
Dr. Bartels and Dr. Pizarro then correlated the results from the trolleyology with those from the personality tests. They found a strong link between utilitarian answers to moral dilemmas(push the fat guy off the bridge)and personalities that were psychopathic, Machiavellian or tended to view life as meaningless. Utilitarians, this suggests, may add to the sum of human happiness, but they are not very happy people themselves.
That does not make utilitarianism wrong. Crafting legislation—one of the main things that Bentham and Mill wanted to improve—inevitably involves riding roughshod over someone’s interests. Utilitarianism provides a plausible framework for deciding who should get trampled. The results obtained by Dr. Bartels and Dr. Pizarro do, though, raise questions about the type of people who you want making the laws. Psychopathic, Machiavellian misanthropes? Apparently, yes. [br] The phrase "riding roughshod over" in the last paragraph probably means
选项
A、reflecting upon.
B、resting upon.
C、trampling upon.
D、looking upon.
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3248355.html
相关试题推荐
TeampurchasingisanewwaytobuythingsontheInternet,whichisbecomin
Therearesomanythingsaboutourlivesthatbelongtothecontentofcultur
Therearesomanythingsaboutourlivesthatbelongtothecontentofcultur
Therearesomanythingsaboutourlivesthatbelongtothecontentofcultur
Therearesomanythingsaboutourlivesthatbelongtothecontentofcultur
Therearesomanythingsaboutourlivesthatbelongtothecontentofcultur
"Wordsarenamesorlabelsforthings."Thisviewiscalled______insemanticse
Thephysicaldistancebetweenspeakerscanindicateanumberofthingsandca
HowtoReduceStressLifeisfullofthingsthatcauseus
HowtoReduceStressLifeisfullofthingsthatcauseus
随机试题
[originaltext]M:MissGreen,ItoldDr.SmiththatIwouldcallhiminthePari
[A]continue[B]control[C]countries[D]dynamic[E]emphasize[F]ignore
诊断急性血管内溶血最有意义的阳性结果是A.血红蛋白血症和血红蛋白尿 B.黄疸
可兴奋组织的强度一时间曲线上任何一点代表()A.强度阈值 B.时间阈值
( )即一切可公开获得的有关公司财务及其发展前景等方面的信息。A.历史信息
患儿,11岁,皮肤紫癜反复出现3年余,瘀斑瘀点颜色紫暗,间或出现鼻衄、齿衄,面色
古蔡法检查砷盐时,砷斑的组分为A.KIB.HgBrC.AsH↑D.AsH(HgB
作为整体,中国在世界上举足轻重;但作为个人,不少中国人还觉得自己一无所有。国家之
面谈结束后,如客户的贷款申请不予考虑,调查人员应()表明银行立场,耐心解释原
女性患者,67岁,右手抖动、行走缓慢已4年,经过神经科检查后考虑为帕金森病。此病
最新回复
(
0
)