首页
登录
职称英语
The Nanny State By the time they get to school, it’s
The Nanny State By the time they get to school, it’s
游客
2023-07-26
27
管理
问题
The Nanny State
By the time they get to school, it’s too late. The realisation that neglectful parenting in a child’s earliest years can ruin its chances for life is shaping a new, expensive and interventionist approach to families in Britain. The government has increased spending on financial support to children by 64%, to £ 24 billion( $ 41 billion), since Labour came to power in 1997. In the latest splurge, it announced an extra£ I billion for childcare, advice for struggling parents and cash benefits.
Intervention in infancy is increasingly popular in America and in Europe, among all shades of opinion. Most leftwingers accept that bad parenting is not only about poverty; most conservatives accept that working mothers are not its sole cause.
Disadvantage is clearly passed on early, and not just through the genes. There is evidence that, by the time they get to school, many dim two-year-olds from good homes have overtaken bright children from bad ones. Being read to, played with, properly fed and cuddled all hugely increase the likelihood of success in later life. Conversely, bad parenting increases the risk of everything from dropping out of school to illness, and eventually jail.
The problems are working out what to do and then making it happen. The British approach, under file overall title of Sure Start, has several strands. One, aimed at 400,000 children in the poorest fifth of the country, is, in effect, supplemental parenting: free places in high-quality nurseries and creches, coupled with energetic advice-giving, a new network of children’s centres, and home visits from volunteers. Then there is the general expansion of nursery’ education. Already every four-yearold has the right to 2hours of state-financed nursery care a day. In 2004 that will include three-year-olds.
Third is the plan to cut child poverty by a quarter by next year, and "end" it in 2020. But poverty, like cruelty, is hard to define. The government’s definition, based on 60% of the median income, is a shifting target: as earnings rise, so does poverty. Moreover, not all cash-strapped parents are bad at raising children.
Nonetheless, the government has energetically raised family benefits and tax credits. The poorest 20% of families with children, it says, will be £ 2,900 a year better off in real terms than before Labour took power in 1997. For single-earners with two or more children, policies are even more redistributive.
The money and effort that have gone into improving life for Britain’s infants are the government’s proudest boast—especially as other public-service reforms are looking increasingly tattered and battered. But problems lurk behind the determination. For a start, these policies are net necessarily compatible. Generous benefits distort the labour market and may encourage feckless behaviour. Frank Field, an iconoclastic Labour MP, notes that benefits for single mothers penalise those in stable relationships, which are clearly associated with good parenting.
Encouraging mothers of young children to find jobs is another good thing: it benefits both them and the family budget. But if it means their children are dumped in front of the telly at a cheap childminder, the kids may be worse off than if they were at hone with mum.
The government’s unwillingness to pass judgment on bad parents also weakens this approach. The rhetoric around Sure Start is swathed with waffle about "inclusivity" and being "non-judgmental". "I don’t have the right to call someone a bad parent," says Jane Cole, a senior Sure Start adviser. Don’t blame parents, she says, but society. But studies of similar intervention in early childhood in America show it works best when programmes clearly tell parents what to do and why.
Sure Start has almost nothing to say about the benefits of reading aloud, or the perils of too mnch television. According to a sceptic close to the scheme, there is too much about boosting parents’ self-esteem and too little attention to making a real difference to children’s lives.
That leads on to the biggest question of all: whether this sort of intervention works. The statistical evidence from well-established programmes in America is at best mixed: the chihtren in greatest need tend to benefit least. A big study duc out in 2006 will answer the question definitively, but Krista Kafer of the Heritage Foundation, an American think-tank, fears that "all it really does is make us feel better as a society". Scandinavian countries have spent heavily on infants for decades, and the inheritance of disadvantage seems to have decreased—though it is difficult to prove that the two are connected. The British government’s splurge on children is based on the hope that they are. [br] The rhetoric around Sure Start is swathed with waffle about"______" and being "______".
选项
答案
inclusivity, nonjudgmental
解析
答案在第九段。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/2869855.html
相关试题推荐
[originaltext]M:Ican’tbelievethatwe’realmostoutofhighschool.W:Ican
[originaltext]M:Ican’tbelievethatwe’realmostoutofhighschool.W:Ican
Theschoolmastertoldhisstudentsthat______(要想进入大学)wasbystrictexaminatio
SchoolsacrossChinaareracingtoimplementtheEducationMinistry’sdecre
SchoolsacrossChinaareracingtoimplementtheEducationMinistry’sdecre
SchoolsacrossChinaareracingtoimplementtheEducationMinistry’sdecre
SchoolsacrossChinaareracingtoimplementtheEducationMinistry’sdecre
Themainideaofthesebusinessschoolacademiesisappealing.Inawordwhe
Themainideaofthesebusinessschoolacademiesisappealing.Inawordwhe
Themainideaofthesebusinessschoolacademiesisappealing.Inawordwhe
随机试题
黄果树瀑布(HuangguoshuWaterfall)享有“中华第一瀑”之盛誉,是亚洲最大的瀑布,也是世界上最壮观的瀑布之一。它位于贵州省安顺市的白水
加热或重金属盐等可以使蛋白质变性,变性蛋白质的理化性质改变,生物活性丧失,其分子
社会公德是该社会各个社会集团、社会阶层都应当遵循的共同道德要求,它反映了道德要求
流水施工的组织方式通常有()。A、平行施工 B、顺次施工 C、等节奏施工
有关SA.RS的传播途径正确的是A.患者的粪便一般没有传染性 B.不经消化道传
拟建某建设项目,固定资产投资总额5058.90万元(不含建设期贷款利息,但其中包
气候是一定地区里经过多年观察所得到的概括性的气象情况,包括()。A.日照
某车间轮班生产某产品的产量任务为2000件,每个工人的班产量定额为5件,定额完成
国际上通行的宏观经济监测指标是()。A.GDP平减指数 B.生产价格指
施工质量控制难度大的客观原因主要是由于建筑产品生产具有()。A.工程的固定性
最新回复
(
0
)