首页
登录
职称英语
Cocoa grown organically on trees within the shade of the rain forest canopy comm
Cocoa grown organically on trees within the shade of the rain forest canopy comm
游客
2024-01-12
15
管理
问题
Cocoa grown organically on trees within the shade of the rain forest canopy commands a premium price. However, acquiring and maintaining the certification that allows the crop to be sold as organically grown is very time-consuming and laborious. Meanwhile, the price premium for the grower is about 30 percent, whereas cocoa trees grown in full sun using standard techniques can have twice the yield of organic, shade-grown trees. Financially, therefore, standard techniques are the better choice for the farmer.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
选项
A、Cocoa can be grown only in a climate that has the temperature and moisture characteristics of a tropical rain forest.
B、Cocoa trees grown using standard techniques require costly applications of fertilizer and pesticides, unlike shade-grown trees.
C、Although organically grown cocoa has long commanded a price premium over cocoa grown using standard techniques, its price has fluctuated considerably during that period.
D、Cocoa is not the only cash crop that can be raised on plots that leave the rain forest canopy overhead essentially intact.
E、Governments and international conservation organizations are working to streamline organic certification so as to relieve farmers of unnecessary work.
答案
B
解析
Argument Evaluation
Situation Cocoa grown organically under the rain forest canopy can obtain a price premium of 30 percent for the grower. But the certification needed for the cocoa to be sold as organic is time-consuming and laborious. Since cocoa grown in full sun by standard (non-organic) techniques can have twice the yield, it is concluded that standard techniques are better financially for the farmer.
Reasoning Among the pieces of information presented, which one, assuming it is accurate, would most weaken the argument if added to the given information? Specific information about the costs associated with growing cocoa using standard techniques is lacking in the given information. For example, does use of the "standard techniques" entail lower or higher costs than use of organic techniques? If we had information that the costs are much higher, such information would tend to weaken the argument—unless we also knew that the much higher yields more than compensate for the much higher costs. If we had information that consumers are becoming increasingly concerned about chemical residues in cocoa, that information would also tend to weaken the argument.
A If this is true, then the cocoa grown both in rain forest shade and in full sun satisfies the climate requirement.
B Correct. This tells us that use of chemical pesticides and fertilizers entails very high costs for growers; moreover, such use of chemicals risks making the cocoa less attractive to consumers, ultimately impacting the grower’s financial benefits.
C If this were true only of the organic cocoa described in the given information, then it would tend to reinforce the argument rather than weaken it. If it were true of both kinds of cocoa, then it would neither strengthen nor weaken the argument.
D This information has no obvious bearing on the question asked.
E This information suggests that costs associated with growing organic cocoa may eventually decrease and the profits increase. But this does not weaken the argument as given, since its conclusion concerns what growing techniques are currently best for farmers.
The correct answer is B.
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3357193.html
相关试题推荐
Theparkwas______easywalkingdistanceofourhotel.A、withinB、insideC、aboutD
Inaforest150deerwerecaught,taggedwithelectronicmarkers,thenreleased.
Neotropicalcoastalmangroveforestsareusually“zonal,”withcertainmangr
AtaxidriverpurchasedfourtiresoftheToughgripbrandforhiscab.Withinsi
Within20yearsitwillprobablybepossibletoidentifythegeneticsusceptibil
Sedimentaryrockhardenswithintheearth’scrustaslayersofmatteraccumulat
Areportonacidrainconcluded,"MostforestsinCanadaarenotbeingdamagedb
Oneofeverytwonewbusinessesfailwithintwoyears.A、failB、failsC、shouldfa
Thefigureofthejaguar,beingarecurringsymbolwithinOlmecart,isprominen
Unlikeahurricane,whichcanbeobservedfromwithin,atornadoissosmalltha
随机试题
[originaltext]W:Hello.NancyEllisspeaking.M:Hello,Dr.Ellis,myname’sDa
Isyourfamilyinterestedinbuyingadog?Adogcanbeahappy【36】toyourf
在面向对象方法中,不同对象收到同一消息可以产生完全不同的结果,这一现象称为(
A.再生障碍性贫血 B.溶血性贫血 C.急性白血病 D.血小板减少性紫癜
A.子宫脱垂Ⅰ度重型 B.子宫脱垂Ⅰ度轻型 C.子宫脱垂Ⅱ度重型 D.子宫
能反转肾上腺素升压作用的药物是A.利血平B.酚苄明C.甲氧那明D.阿托品E.普萘
在实际估价中,待开发房地产状况可以分为()三大类。A.可供开发的土地 B
属于中央预算的政府采购项目,其集中采购目录由()确定并公布。A、国务院B、全国
胃黏膜渗血患者可首选哪种药物治疗A.肾上腺素 B.多巴胺 C.异丙肾上腺素
A.感染性休克 B.神经性休克 C.心源性休克 D.创伤性休克 E.失血
最新回复
(
0
)