首页
登录
职称英语
1 I don’t know if gay marriage will have all the bad effects predicted by
1 I don’t know if gay marriage will have all the bad effects predicted by
游客
2023-12-20
50
管理
问题
1 I don’t know if gay marriage will have all the bad effects predicted by conservatives, but it’s already having one they didn’t foresee, driving them stark, raving mad. They’ve set out to prove they can devise one remedy after another that not only is unnecessary but also worse than the problem it’s supposed to fix.
2 Their discombobulation began when the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court struck down the state’s ban on gay unions and ordered the state to issue marriage licenses to same sex couples. Never mind that the ruling had no effect beyond the Bay State. From the reaction, you’d think same-sex marriage was going to be mandatory for all. The call went out that something, anything, had to be done.
3 First, critics of the decision offered a constitutional amendment banning same-sex unions anywhere in America. Despite being endorsed by President Bush, it blew up on the launch pad. Constitutional amendments need 67 votes to pass the Senate, and this one attracted only 48 supporters.
4 So conservatives promptly came up with another idea. If you can’t amend the Constitution, you can make it irrelevant. They propose to do this by taking the whole issue away from federal judges. In July, the House of Representatives approved the Marriage Protection Act, which effectively bars any federal court, including the Supreme Court, from hearing challenges to laws against same-sex unions.
5 Why is it needed? "This legislation ensures the people and the states will have a say in marriage policy," said House Judiciary Committee Chairman James Sensenbrenner. It may come as news that conservatives want the states to have a say in marriage policy. The constitutional amendment, after all, would have done exactly the opposite—forbidding any state from legalizing gay marriage.
6 In fact, federal law already protects the right of the states to do whatever they darn well please. In 1996, Republicans were worried that Hawaii was going to allow same-sex marriage and, conceivably, force other states to accept gay unions transacted there. So, over the howls of gay-rights groups, they pushed through the Defense of Marriage Act, denying federal recognition of same-sex marriages and assuring each state the power to do likewise.
7 Back then, DOMA was championed as a way to protect traditional marriage as well as democracy. Former Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott (R-Miss.) described it as "a pre emptive measure to make sure that a handful of judges in a single state cannot impose a radical social agenda upon the entire nation." But now, having failed to get their constitutional amendment, conservatives want to make sure supporters of same-sex marriage can’t persuade the Supreme Court to issue a decision nullifying DOMA.
8 Barring judicial review of a category of laws is not exactly a conservative notion. Courts have taken responsibility for deciding the constitutionality of laws since the early years of the republic, a role set out for them in the Federalist Papers.
9 Stripping them of that power is a drastic step. Conservatives say we need to keep hyperactive judges from shoving gay marriage down all our throats. But who says they’re going to? The Constitution long has been understood to protect state power over marriage-- even in the dark days when Southern states refused to accept interracial marriages from elsewhere. DOMA reaffirms the point by stipulating that states are free to treat gay weddings as the equivalent of Monopoly money.
10 Of course, it’s theoretically possible that the Rehnquist Supreme Court, dominated by Republican appointees, suddenly will discover a constitutional right to same-sex marriage. But worrying about that is like worrying that A1 Sharpton will take a vow of silence. The Marriage Protection Act amounts to a pre-emptive strike based on a preposterous fear.
11 It would do serious collateral damage, though. The bill would set a precedent that sooner or later will bite conservatives on the bottom. Liberals could bar courts from using the 2nd Amendment to strike down gun control measures, or from invoking the 5th Amendment’s protection of property rights to block environmental regulations.
12 Once we start down this road, says University of Chicago law professor Cass Sunstein, "there’s no place to stop." Court stripping, he predicts, would become "an irresistible tool" whenever Congress gets the urge to pass a constitutionally dubious measure. This is worse than a zero sum game. It’s more like the old vision of nuclear war: Mutual Assured Destruction.
13 To react to one state’s legalization of gay marriage by mutilating the Constitution or wrecking the separation of powers is the equivalent of elephants stampeding at the sight of a mouse. It’s more sensible just to tolerate the little critter. [br] The critics managed to take the following reactions to the ruling EXCEPT ______.
选项
A、proposing a constitutional amendment
B、making it impossible for federal judges to intervene in related issues
C、denying federal recognition of same-sex marriages
D、banning same-sex unions
答案
C
解析
本题为细节归纳题。据第3段第1句可排除A;据第4段可排除B3据第6段最后1句可排除D。D曲解了第3段第1句,批评者们并没有能够取缔同性联合会。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3288593.html
相关试题推荐
Inthe1950s,thepioneersofartificialintelligence(AI)predictedthat,b
Inthe1950s,thepioneersofartificialintelligence(AI)predictedthat,b
Inthe1950s,thepioneersofartificialintelligence(AI)predictedthat,b
Canyouspotagoodmarriage?IwasprettysureIcould,startingwithmyown
Marriagemaybeaboutlove,butdivorceisabusiness.Forglobalcouples—bo
Marriagemaybeaboutlove,butdivorceisabusiness.Forglobalcouples—bo
Marriagemaybeaboutlove,butdivorceisabusiness.Forglobalcouples—bo
Whencanthedroughtbeexpectedtoend?[br]Thedroughtispredictedtocause
Homophonesareoftenemployedtocreatepunsfordesiredeffectsof_____.A、humou
1Idon’tknowifgaymarriagewillhaveallthebadeffectspredictedby
随机试题
Whichofthefollowingitemsarereportedasacurrentliabilityonthebalance
Thedirectraysofthesuntouchtheequatorandstrikenorthwardtowardthe
下列各项中,关于河南红色旅游景点的说法正确的有( )。A.新县被誉为“红军的故
根据有关规定,一般来说,基金份额持有人的权利不包括()。A.参与分配清算后的剩
( )就是要在指导投资者分析投资问题、获得必要信息、进行理性选择的同时,致力于改
血块收缩能力增高见于A、原发性血小板减少性紫癜B、血小板增多症C、血小板无力
对成人实施心肺复苏抢救时,按压通气之比为()。A.单人施救为30:2,双人为1
法律关系的构成要素是指( )A、主体和客体 B、权利和义务 C、主体、客体和
某男性患者,30岁。因龋坏拔除,给予2%利多卡因行下牙槽神经阻滞麻醉,未行注射器
甲电池制造厂主要生产销售电池,其将自产的电池用于下列各项用途,应当缴纳消费税的有
最新回复
(
0
)