首页
登录
学历类
In the idealized version of how science
In the idealized version of how science
考试题库
2022-08-02
57
问题
In the idealized version of how science is done, facts about the world are waiting to be observed and collected by objective researchers who use the scientific method to carry out their work. But in the everyday practice of science, discovery frequently follows an ambiguous and complicated route. We aim to be objective, but we cannot escape the context of our unique life experience. Prior knowledge and interest influence what we experience, what we think our experiences mean, and the subsequent actions we take. Opportunities for misinterpretation, error, and self-deception abound. Consequently, discovery claims should be thought of as protoscience. Similar to newly staked mining claims, they are full of potential. But it takes collective scrutiny and acceptance to transform a discovery claim into a mature discovery. This is the credibility process, through which the individual researcher’s me, here, now becomes the community’sanyone, anywhere, anytime. Objective knowledge is the goal, not the starting point. Once a discovery claim becomes public, the discoverer receives intellectual credit. But, unlike with mining claims, the community takes control of what happens next. Within the complex social structure of the scientific community, researchers make discoveries; editors and reviewers act as gatekeepers by controlling the publication process; other scientists use the new finding to suit their own purposes; and finally, the public (including other scientists) receives the new discovery and possibly accompanying technology. As a discovery claim works it through the community, the interaction and confrontation between shared and competing beliefs about the science and the technology involved transforms an individual’s discovery claim into the community’s credible discovery. Two paradoxes exist throughout this credibility process. First, scientific work tends to focus on some aspect of prevailing Knowledge that is viewed as incomplete or incorrect. Little reward accompanies duplication and confirmation of what is already known and believed. The goal is new-search, not re-search. Not surprisingly, newly published discovery claims and credible discoveries that appear to be important and convincing will always be open to challenge and potential modification or refutation by future researchers. Second, novelty itself frequently provokes disbelief. Nobel Laureate and physiologist Albert Szent-Gy?rgyi once described discovery as “seeing what everybody has seen and thinking what nobody has thought.” But thinking what nobody else has thought and telling others what they have missed may not change their views. Sometimes years are required for truly novel discovery claims to be accepted and appreciated. In the end, credibility “happens” to a discovery claim—a process that corresponds to what philosopher Annette Baier has described as the commons of the mind. “We reason together, challenge, revise, and complete each other’s reasoning and each other’s conceptions of reason.”Albert Szent-Gy?rgyi would most likely agree that _______.A. scientific claims will survive challengesB. discoveries today inspire future researchC. efforts to make discoveries are justifiedD. scientific work calls for a critical mind
选项
A. scientific claims will survive challenges
B. discoveries today inspire future research
C. efforts to make discoveries are justified
D. scientific work calls for a critical mind
答案
D
解析
由题干中Albert Szent-Gy?rgyi定位到第四段,该段倒数第三句指出:...Albert Szent-Gy?rgyi once described discovery as “seeing what everybody has seen and thinking what nobody has thought”,可知Albert Szent-Gy?rgyi认为科学发现就是见别人之所见,想别人之未想,也就是需要进行批判性思考,因此正确答案为D项。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/xueli/2699132.html
本试题收录于:
英语一研究生题库研究生入学分类
英语一研究生
研究生入学
相关试题推荐
Intheidealizedversionofhowscience
Intheidealizedversionofhowscience
Inthe2006filmversionofTheDevilWe
Inthe2006filmversionofTheDevilWe
Inthe2006filmversionofTheDevilWe
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextrar
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextrar
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextrar
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextrar
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextrar
随机试题
[originaltext]CLARE:Hi,Grant.Whatsortofcompetitiondoyouthinkweshould
TherighttopursuehappinessispromisedtoAmericansbytheUSConstitutio
如图,上部为气体下部为水的封闭容器装有U形水银测压计,其中1、2、3点位于同一平
儿童胸外按压频率是A.80~100次/分B.100次/分C.100~120次/分
学生李某发现自己的钱包不见了,怀疑是同桌张某拿了,于是班主任就把张某叫到办公室对
某膳食调查的人群由三类人员组成,其中能量RNI为3200kcal的有12人,31
患者,女,人工流产术后3周,阴道出血时多时少,色暗红,有时夹血块,腹痛,B超提示
在基本的量本利图中,当一定时期内,产品价格不变时,销售收入随产销数量增加而增加,
某新建工程,地下3层,地上30层,总建筑面积53650㎡,基坑深度为
最新回复
(
0
)