首页
登录
职称英语
Finding something new to say about America’s love affair with the death penal
Finding something new to say about America’s love affair with the death penal
游客
2025-04-25
18
管理
问题
Finding something new to say about America’s love affair with the death penalty is not easy. The subject not only arouses intense emotions, it has produced an ocean of comment from lawyers, judges, politicians, campaigners, statisticians, social scientists and quite a few demagogues. Nevertheless, Franklin Zimring, one of America’s leading criminologists, has managed to rise above this cacophony to write a thought-provoking and genuinely original book, The Contradictions of American Capital Punishment’, which deserves to become a classic.
Mr. Zimring tackles head-on the most puzzling question of all- why are Americans so determined to keep the death penalty when nearly all other developed democracies have given it up, and now view it as barbaric? In the past two decades, attitudes in America and Europe have diverged so much that any dialogue on the subject has been replaced by blank incomprehension, and America’s retention of capital punishment has become a significant diplomatic irritant. For European governments the abolition of capital punishment is a human-rights priority, and they have expended valuable political capital in trying to achieve it. American governments, Republican and Democratic, insist that the death penalty has nothing to do with human-rights, and deeply resent European efforts to make its abolition an international norm.
The difference between European and American attitudes, says Mr. Zimring, is not the breadth of support for the death penalty, but its depth. At the time of the death penalty’s abolition in each developed country, a majority similar to America’s, currently 65%, wanted to keep it, according to opinion polls. But when European political elites turned against it after the Second World War, electorates acquiesced. Today most Europeans probably would not want it back.
The death penalty is a far more contentious issue in America, says Mr. Zimring, because the debate about it draws on a cherished American political tradition which does not exist anywhere else: vigilante justice. Many death-penalty supporters see executions not as acts of a distant or unreliable government, or even as a crime-control measure, but as an instrument of local, community justice, a form of vengeance on behalf of the victims’ relatives.
In a startling analysis, Mr. Zimring shows that most executions are performed in a few states in the south and south-west where the lynching of African-Americans, other forms of mob violence and six-shooter justice were most endemic at the end of the 19th and first half of the 20 centuries. Opinion-poll support for the death penalty may be fairly uniform across America, and 38 states have the death penalty on their books, but many states hardly ever execute anyone. The vast bulk of executions take place only where the values of the lynch mob have endured, he says.
Many people will find this linkage distasteful. But Mr. Zimring marshals a powerful case for it, and sceptics will have to reply to his evidence, not just brush the argument aside. Americans’ distrust of overweening government power is as deeply rooted a tradition as vigilante justice, Mr. Zimring concedes. However, when it comes to the death penalty, this distrust is manifest not in an abolitionist movement, as in other countries, but in the maze of legal-appeals procedures which mean that most murderers condemned to death spend years, even decades, on death row. More death-row inmates are likely to die of old age than by execution. Neither supporters nor opponents of the death penalty are happy with this odd result.
What Americans really want is an error-free death penalty, but this can never be guaranteed, as the recent spate of death-row exonerations has shown. Moreover, Mr. Zimring argues that Americans’ ambivalence about capital punishment can never be resolved. Sooner or later, one of these competing traditions - a regard for careful legal processes to second-guess and constrain government actions, or the desire for vengeance - will have to give way. That will not happen easily. Both date back to the country’s founding.
Mr. Zimring believes, on scanty evidence, that Americans will eventually abandon vigilante values, and abolish the death penalty. But he admits that this will be a messy, bitter affair. And he could well be wrong. His analysis might equally point to another, less palatable outcome: a sweeping aside of legal constraints, and a more rapid pace of executions. [br] What is the main purpose of this article?
选项
A、to discuss capital punishment in America
B、to support Mr. Zimring’s views on capital punishment
C、to review Mr. Zimring’s book on capital punishment
D、to help sell Mr. Zimring’s book on capital punishment
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/4052644.html
相关试题推荐
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
TheordinaryfamilycolonialNorthAmericawasprimarilyconcernedwithshee
随机试题
Whatdotheextraordinarilysuccessfulcompanieshaveincommon?Tofindout
[originaltext]M:Whatdoyouthinkofthegovernment’snewtaxcutproposal?W:
对于糖尿病人运动治疗,运动前的胰岛素应注射于()A.运动肌肉 B.下肢
患者,女性,32岁,患风湿性心脏病二尖瓣狭窄10年,近半年来上二层楼即感心悸气短
下列哪项不是阴虚风动的临床表现A、手足蠕动 B、低热起伏 C、脉细如丝 D
为让班会开得成功,我选了一篇课文改写成剧本,准备排演课本剧。第二天,我在班上说了
我国2011年固定资本形成总额比居民消费支出大约高出多少?() A.20.
下列现象属于学习迁移的是()。A.温故而知新 B.学而时习之 C.近朱者
(2015年真题)下列各项,不通过“长期应付款”科目核算的有()。A.付款期限
一般来说,国债的政策功能包括( )。A.弥补财政赤字 B.筹集建设资金 C
最新回复
(
0
)