首页
登录
职称英语
Architects are hopeless when it comes to deciding whether the public will vi
Architects are hopeless when it comes to deciding whether the public will vi
游客
2025-04-19
42
管理
问题
Architects are hopeless when it comes to deciding whether the public will view their designs as marvels or monstrosities, according to a study by Canadian psychologists. They say designers should go back to school to learn about ordinary people’s tastes.
Many buildings that appeal to architects get the thumbs down from the public. Robert Gifford of the University of Victoria in British Columbia decided to find out whether architects understand public preferences and simply disagree with them, or fail to understand the lay person’s view.
With his colleague Graham Brown, he asked 25 experienced architects to look at photos of 42 large buildings in the US, Canada, Europe and Hong Kong. The architects predicted how the public would rate the buildings on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 represented "terrible" and 10 "excellent". A further 27 people who were not architects also scored the buildings out of 10. In addition, eight architects gave their own personal ratings of the buildings.
The three groups tended to agree among themselves on a building’s merits. And architects correctly predicted that lay people would on average rate buildings higher than they did themselves. But for individual building, the architect’s perceptions of what the lay people would think were often way off the mark. "Some architects are quite good at predicting lay preferences, but others are not only poor at it, they get it backwards." says Gifford.
For instance, architects gave the Stockley Park Building B-3 offices in London a moderate rating of 5.2. They thought the public would like it much better, predicting a rating of 6.3. But the public actually disliked the offices, and gave it 4.7. Gifford thinks that lay people respond to specific features of buildings, such as durability and originality, and hope to pin down what they are.
"Architects in architecture school need to be taught how lay people think about buildings," Gifford concludes. He doesn’t think designers should pander to the lowest common denominator, but suggests they should aspire towards buildings that appeal to the public and architects alike, such as the Bank of China building in Hong Kong.
Marco Goldschmeid of the Richard Rogers Partnership, designers of the Millennium Dome in London, thinks the study is flawed. "The authors have assumed, wrongly, that buildings can be meaningfully judged from photographs rather than actual visits," he says. Goldschmeid thinks it would be more significant and interesting to look at the divergence of public taste between generations. [br] What does the passage mainly deal with?
选项
A、How to design attractive buildings
B、Architects need to understand public tastes
C、How lay people view buildings
D、Different tastes between architects and the public
答案
B
解析
根据文章内容可知,本文主要讨论的是建筑师应该多了解外行公众的建筑品位。而且第一段就开门见山,点明主旨:建筑师无法判断公众将怎样对待他们的建筑设计,建筑设计师应该重新回到学校学习一下大众对建筑的品位。据此判断,答案是B。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/4044986.html
相关试题推荐
Sheansweredwithan______"No"totherequestthatsheattendthepublichearin
Auctionsarepublicsalesofgoods,conductedbyanofficiallyapprovedauct
Auctionsarepublicsalesofgoods,conductedbyanofficiallyapprovedauct
Auctionsarepublicsalesofgoods,conductedbyanofficiallyapprovedauct
Willyou._______myarticletofindoutwhetherI’vemadeanymistakes?A、lookaf
Thepublicmightwellsanctionawiderrangeofprogrammingthanwouldstrictly
Auctionsarepublicsalesofgoods,conductedbyanofficiallyapprovedaucti
Auctionsarepublicsalesofgoods,conductedbyanofficiallyapprovedaucti
Althoughthegovernmentstillenjoysahighlevelofpublicsupport,thecrimep
Publicationofthissurveyhadoriginallybeenintendedtocoincidewiththe
随机试题
[originaltext]ExitpollsinIsraelshowthatPrimeMinisterArielSharon’su
Afacialexpressionresultsfromoneormoremotionsorpositionsofthemus
Manyaspecialist______lookingforwardtoattendingthatconferencenowandthe
[originaltext]M:Why?Mary,youaresweatingheavily.Wherehaveyoubeen?W:I
IsthereenoughoilbeneaththeArcticNationalWildlifeRefuge(保护区)(ANWR)to
SydneyOperaHousemustbeoneofthemostrecognizableimagesofthemodern
34.交流采样测量装置投入运行后的检验包括周期检验、临时检验和现场比较。
风险对房地产投资决策的影响包括()A:根据项目风险大小确定相应的投资收益水平B
中国甲公司与法国乙公司商谈进口特种钢材,乙公司提供了买卖该种钢材的格式合同,两国
根据支付结算法律制度的规定,银行汇票的提示付款期限为自出票日起一定期限,持票人超
最新回复
(
0
)