首页
登录
职称英语
Municipal bans on smoking in restaurants and bars are highly controversial, but
Municipal bans on smoking in restaurants and bars are highly controversial, but
游客
2025-01-28
8
管理
问题
Municipal
bans on smoking in restaurants and bars are highly controversial, but history shows they can also be highly effective. But are all smoking bans equally successful?
The barkeeper and blogger who writes as "Scribbler50" was outraged when, in 2003, New York City enacted one of the first comprehensive smoking bans in bars and restaurants, "How can a guy and some board just kick us in the teeth like this? This smacks of fascism." If people are aware of the consequences of smoking or visiting places with lots of secondhand smoke, should the government really have to tell us what to do? Won’t people just vote with their feet and smoke even more when they’re at home and away from restrictions?
Scribbler50’s post inspired the physician who blogs as "PalMD" last week to look up the research on the effectiveness of smoking bans. He found several studies showing that not only did workers in restaurants and bars show improved health shortly after the bans were put in place, but smokers themselves also reduced the number of cigarettes they smoked.
Overall, however, smoking rates remain persistently high, despite the common workplace smoking bans. Can other government measures help these smokers live healthier lives, or at least prevent people from taking up the habit?
In the U.S., warning messages have been in place on cigarette packages for decades. But the messages are rather clinical, for example: "Smoking Causes Lung Cancer, Heart Disease, and May Complicate Pregnancy." What if packages contained more dramatic warnings? In January, psychologist and science writer Christian Jarrett looked at a small study of smokers’ reactions to cigarette warnings. The researchers measured self-esteem in student smokers, then showed them cigarette packages with either death-related warnings ("Smokers die earlier") or esteem-related warnings ("Smoking makes you unattractive"). Students who derived self-esteem from smoking and saw the death-related warnings later viewed smoking more positively than those who saw the esteem-related warnings. For students whose smoking wasn’t motivated by self-esteem, the effect was reversed.
So not all anti-smoking messages are equal: Depending on who the message is directed at, a morbid warning on a cigarette label may actually
backfire
.
Scribbler50 for his part, is now a convert favoring smoking restrictions, at least in his narrow limits as a bartender. His patrons who haven’t quit smoking say they smoke a lot less now that they have to go outside to get a nicotine fix. He doesn’t miss emptying ashtrays, or the holier-than-thou customers who complained every time a fellow patron lit up, or working in a smoke-filled bar all night and going home "smelling like you put out a three-alarm".
Would it be right to enact even more restrictions on smoking in the interest of public health? It’s hard to deny that banning smoking in public, indoor spaces has been a huge success. Why not try out some stronger smoking bans? Parents in some areas are already restricted from smoking in cars with children, but I haven’t seen a study that evaluates the success of those measures. Perhaps a state or municipality could try extending the ban to homes, with provisions for studying the results. It’s also possible that stronger measures would be counter-productive, like the stronger warnings on cigarette labels. Maybe we’ll decide that at some level deciding whether or not to smoke should still be an individual choice. Or maybe in a few generations, it won’t be necessary to regulate smoking: There won’t be any smokers left. [br] What is the main idea of the passage?
选项
A、Scribbler50’s attitude toward smoking bans.
B、The research on people’s stopping smoking.
C、The effectiveness of smoking bans.
D、Smoking bans in restaurants and bars.
答案
C
解析
本文先讲禁烟令的实施过程中人们的态度,由此引出对禁烟效果的讨论,还探讨了不同提示语的禁烟效果,最后展望未来禁烟的一些可能性,可以看出,禁烟效果是贯穿全文的主题,故C正确。A“Scribbler50对禁烟的态度”、B“关于人们停止吸烟的研究”和D“餐厅和酒吧的禁烟令”均是文章的细节,不足以概括全文。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3933067.html
相关试题推荐
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,b
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,b
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,b
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,b
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,b
Sallyappearsbeingahardtimeconvincingherhusbandtogiveupsmoking.A、tob
Thegoosequillpenhasagreatsentimentalappealintoday’shighlymechanized
Anyonetryingtobreakabadhabit—whetheritbesmoking,drinking,overeatingo
Sallyappearsbeingahardtimeconvincingherhusbandtogiveupsmoking.A、tob
Municipalbansonsmokinginrestaurantsandbarsarehighlycontroversial,but
随机试题
“实践、认识、再实践、再认识,这种形式,循环往复以至无穷”体现的是(
一般而言,目前临床上适用范围最广的固定义齿桥体龈端形态是A.盖嵴式桥体 B.船
与中医药有关的评审或者鉴定活动,应当A.遵循继承与创新相结合的原则 B.注重中
患者,男,58岁。患"高血压"已近10年,头晕胀痛,耳鸣,梦多寐差,腰膝酸软,头
融市场的构成要素不包括(). A.市场参与者 B.流通渠道 C.金融工具
A. B. C. D.
关于燃烧类型及其特点,以下举例不属于化学自燃的是()。A.火柴受摩擦而着火
在战略规划实施的过程中,有两种情况可能导致企业发展目标和方向发生偏移,一是将分目
中西药联用能够减少西药剂量的药组是A.五倍子与红霉素 B.川芎与氨茶碱 C.
萎缩性胃体胃炎() A.胃酸明显减少 B.胃酸明显增高 C.胃酸升高 D
最新回复
(
0
)