首页
登录
职称英语
(1) "The elephant chart" began life in 2012, hidden in the middle of a World
(1) "The elephant chart" began life in 2012, hidden in the middle of a World
游客
2024-09-10
8
管理
问题
(1) "The elephant chart" began life in 2012, hidden in the middle of a World Bank working paper by Branko Milanovic, an authority on global inequality. It turned a few heads in the New York Times in 2014, then graced Mr Milanovic’s well-received book on global inequality earlier this year. Somewhere along the way it acquired its name, which helped it stampede across social media, brokers’ notes and even a ministerial speech this spring and summer. "I’m about to bring an elephant into the room. A wild, angry, and dangerous elephant," joked Lilianne Ploumen, the Dutch trade minister, last month, before unveiling the chart to her audience. Now, its critics are trying to shoot it.
(2) The distinctively shaped chart summarized the results of a huge number (196) of household surveys across the world. It was created by ranking the world’s population, from the poorest 10% to the richest 1% , in 1988 and again in 2008. At each rank, the chart showed the growth in income between these two years, an era of "high globalization" from the fall of the Berlin Wall to the fall of Lehman Brothers.
(3) When drawn for individual countries, charts of this kind tend to slant upwards (the rich gain more than the poor) or downwards. The global chart was unusual in sloping up, down, then upwards again, like an inverted S on its back, or an elephant raising its trunk. The chart showed big income gains at the middle and very top. But the era of globalization seemed to offer little for the people in between: households in the 75th to 85th percentile of the income distribution seemed scarcely better off in 2008 than they had been 20 years before. They constituted a decile of discontent, squeezed between their own countries’ plutocrats and Asia’s middle class. This dramatic dip in the chart seemed to explain a lot.
(4) But who exactly occupies this dangerous decile? A report this week by Adam Corlett of the Resolution Foundation, a British think-tank, examines this group more closely, taking aim at some simplistic interpretations of the chart. Many people assume the chart shows how people in this controversial income bracket back in 1988 fared over the subsequent 20 years. But that is not quite the case. Instead it compares the people in this bracket in 1988 with people in the same bracket 20 years later. They may not be the same people. They may not belong to the same class. They may not even belong to the same country.
(5) What accounts for the changing constituents of each income bracket? Fast growth will, of course, carry people up the income ranks. Data, dissolution and demography also play a part. The countries included in the 1988 and 2008 rankings differ because data did not exist for both years or because the country did not. In addition, faster population growth among people in the lower reaches of the income distribution will automatically shunt everyone above them further up the income ranks, even without any improvement in their fortunes.
(6) To see why, imagine a simple world populated by 750m poor Southerners and 250m rich Northerners. Imagine that incomes do not change over the next 20 years, but the South’s population doubles. That would increase its share of mankind from 75% to over 85%. For that simple reason, in the 75th to 85th percentiles of the global income distribution poor Southerners would replace rich Northerners. Any comparison of this income bracket with the same bracket 20 years before would thus show a big decline in fortunes, even though no one is worse off.
(7) This will not be new to readers of Mr Milanovic’s academic work. He and his co-author, Christoph Lakner, were quite clear about the shifting composition of the troublesome deciles. Their journal article also included an alternative chart, which does what many people assumed the elephant chart had done: it illustrates how each income group in each country in 1988 fared over the subsequent 20 years. In its shape, the chart looks recognizably elephantine. But the top 1% do markedly less well in this alternative chart than in the more famous one, and even the worst performing groups boast income growth of 20% or more over 20 years.
(8) Both charts show that the world’s rich has gained handsomely in the era of globalization. It also remains true that the lower middle classes in rich countries have fared less well. The elephant shape remains, even if its dimensions are different. But it clarified a misunderstanding shared by many of the pundits and drumbeaters who made such a noise about the rampaging chart. Like the elephant George Orwell described in a famous essay about his time as a colonial policeman in Burma, this one was shot chiefly to silence a crowd. [br] It is indicated in the last paragraph that______.
选项
A、wealth disparity has expanded over the 20 years
B、the middle class has lost ground in globalization
C、people are making too big a fuss about the chart
D、we should shoot the elephant as Orwell did before
答案
C
解析
推断题。作者在倒数第二段分析了另一个备选图表和“大象图表”之间的差别,最后一段指出,澄清人们对“大象图表”的误解,能像奥威尔的散文中讲述的射杀大象事件一样,让聚集围观者安静下来,可见作者认为之前人们对这个图表的反应太大了,因此[C]为答案。最后一段只说到富人收益增加,而富裕国家的中低收人人群表现稍差,不能据此说贫富差距加大,故排除[A];本段第二句虽然说富裕国家的中低收入阶层表现稍差,但是不能因此一概而论,说中产阶级在全球化当中失去阵地,故排除[B];作者在文末提到奥威尔射象一文,是为了进行类比说明,不能做字面理解,故排除[D]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3751308.html
相关试题推荐
AresignationletterwrittenbyamiddleschoolteacherfromHenanprovince
Idon’tknowwhyhe______inthemiddleofasentence.A、brokeawayB、brokeout
PASSAGETHREEInthemiddleofSeptember.文章第二段第三句提到,他选择一年之中海冰量最少的时间进行为期一天的航程,即从九月
(1)"Theelephantchart"beganlifein2012,hiddeninthemiddleofaWorld
(1)"Theelephantchart"beganlifein2012,hiddeninthemiddleofaWorld
(1)"Theelephantchart"beganlifein2012,hiddeninthemiddleofaWorld
AresignationletterwrittenbyamiddleschoolteacherfromHenanProvinces
Thismayhavepreservedtheelephantfrombeingwipedoutaswellasotheranima
Themotoristhadto______toavoidknockingtheoldwomandowninthemiddleoft
Thingswentwellforherduringherearlylifebutinhermiddleageher_____s
随机试题
Aftertheterroristattack,tourists_______________________(被劝告暂时不要去该国旅游).were
[originaltext]Thelaborproblemswerethelatestbadnewsforanindustrytha
2001-2009年,全国重点城市平均地价增长率最高的年份是:() A.2
依据《高强性能混凝土用矿物外加都(GB/T18736)的规定,下列产品代号相对应
对于浅埋松散破碎地层,隧道一般采用()支护方式。A、地表砂浆锚杆 B、超前锚
作废的《药品经营许可证》应建档保存A.5年 B.3年 C.1年 D.3个月
在对数据集中趋势的测度中,适用于偏斜分布的数值型数据的是()。A.均值 B.
下列哪项不符合髓外造血A.是机体对血细胞的需求明显增高的一种代偿 B.多见于儿
苯巴比妥与华法林合用时,后者的抗凝作用减弱,其原因是苯巴比妥有A.吸收减少 B
对浅表和深部真菌感染都有效的抗真菌药物是A.灰黄霉素 B.特比萘芬 C.氟胞
最新回复
(
0
)