首页
登录
职称英语
A federal judge in California has dismissed a lawsuit against the Coca-Co
A federal judge in California has dismissed a lawsuit against the Coca-Co
游客
2024-01-23
27
管理
问题
A federal judge in California has dismissed a lawsuit against the Coca-Cola company which argued that Diet Coke misled people to believe the drink would help them lose weight.
The case was brought by Shana Becerra who said that she had bought and drank Diet Coke because she believed it would contribute to weight loss and healthy weight management. She alleged that Diet Coke had the opposite effect, citing studies that she claimed showed sweeteners with no nutritional value like those used in Diet Coke cause weight gain and increased risk of certain diseases.
Although Coca-Cola’s arguments against the suit were not adequate, Judge William Alsup said the prosecutor failed to show that consumers were likely to be deceived by the advertising.
Alsup dismissed the case because Becerra had not met the requirement that "members of the public are likely to be deceived". "In supermarkets, Diet Coke is displayed next to regular soft drinks and is not sold in the health-food section. Reasonable consumers would understand that Diet Coke merely deletes the calories usually present in regular Coke, and that the caloric reduction will lead to weight loss only as part of an overall sensible diet and exercise regimen (养生法) dependent on individual metabolism," Alsup said in the decision.
Alsup said the studies cited by Becerra suggest a correlation between Diet Coke-type drinks and weight gain, but they do not suggest causation. He added that one of the studies even says that weight gain is "due to the behavior of consumers, rather than the effects of nonnutritive sweeteners." Alsup also rejected the idea that Diet Coke advertising would suggest to consumers that the soft drink led to weight loss as " reasonable consumers understand that advertising will feature healthy and attractive consumers enjoying the subject products and will not star the unhealthy and unfit."
The decision on Tuesday, said that the prosecutor has until March 22 to file a motion to amend the complaint. A spokesperson for the Coca-Cola company said they were content with the fact that the court dismissed prosecutor’s baseless complaint. [br] Why did Judge William Alsup dismiss the charge?
选项
A、Because the prosecutor couldn’t provide solid evidence to support her lawsuit.
B、Because the Coca-Cola company didn’t do anything wrong.
C、Because he was reasonable enough to know the effects of soft drinks.
D、Because the consumer made no sense in this lawsuit.
答案
A
解析
细节辨认题。定位部分指出,尽管可口可乐公司针对这项诉讼的辩护并不充分,威廉·阿尔苏普法官还是认为原告无法证明消费者有可能受到该广告的欺骗,没有达到“公众成员们有可能受到欺骗”这一要求。由此可见,法官之所以驳回上诉是因为证据不足,故答案为A。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3387767.html
相关试题推荐
AfederaljudgeinCaliforniahasdismissedalawsuitagainsttheCoca-Colac
AfederaljudgeinCaliforniahasdismissedalawsuitagainsttheCoca-Colac
Backin1975,economistsplottedrisinglifeexpectanciesagainstcountries’
Backin1975,economistsplottedrisinglifeexpectanciesagainstcountries’
Californiahasbeenfacingadroughtformanyyearsnow,withcertainarease
Californiahasbeenfacingadroughtformanyyearsnow,withcertainarease
Californiahasbeenfacingadroughtformanyyearsnow,withcertainarease
[originaltext]A9-year-oldCentralCaliforniaboybravedstrongcurrentsandco
AfederaljudgeinCaliforniahasdismissedalawsuitagainsttheCoca-Co
AfederaljudgeinCaliforniahasdismissedalawsuitagainsttheCoca-Co
随机试题
ThereasonBeethovenwentawaytothecountryis______.A、thathewasgraduallyg
Iaskedsuccessfulpeoplewhatthesecretoftheirsuccesswas.I【B1】______a
TheKalinagotribe,ontheislandofDominica,isundersomehistoricpopula
当某商品当年年底商品存货量增加时,则表示()。A、当年商品的供应量大于需求量B、当年商品的供应量小于需求量C、下年的商品期货价格很可能会下跌D、下
建设单位不得对勘察、设计、施工、工程监理等单位提出不符合建设工程安全生产法律、法
通用汽车(中国)投资有限公司分批召回了存在问题的国产雪佛兰以及别克品牌车辆,这些
甲公司生产某项产品,单位成本为每台10元,产品的月销售量平均为10000台。为在
就业歧视,是指用人单位没有合法依据,对未来潜在的就业人员自行作出各种限制性条款,
(2014真题)根据《建设工程工程量清单计价规范》GB50500-2013,关于
男,70岁。1小时前呕血1OOOml。既往史:HBsAg(+)20年,冠心病史1
最新回复
(
0
)