首页
登录
职称英语
The questions in this group are based on the content of a passage. After reading
The questions in this group are based on the content of a passage. After reading
游客
2024-01-13
51
管理
问题
The questions in this group are based on the content of a passage. After reading the passage, choose the best answer to each question. Answer all questions following the passage on the basis of what is
stated
or
implied
in the passage.
Pretty much everybody agrees that clean air is a good thing, right? Evidently not so. Since the 1960s, when people started talking about clean air in the first place, the American energy industry, which includes coal companies, oil companies, and utility companies, has dragged its heels on every initiative to improve the quality of the air we breathe. Even after the Clean Air Act of 1970 and its amendments in 1977 and 1990 made it clear that controlling air pollution is a national priority, these companies have found tricks and loopholes to avoid compliance.
Perhaps the most egregious loophole is the one that allows older power plants to disregard limits on sulfux dioxide emissions until they undergo a major renovation, at which point they have to comply. Sulfur dioxide from coal-burning power plants is the primary cause of acid rain in North America. The Clean Air Act states that when coal-burning power plants upgrade their equipment, they must then comply with sulfur dioxide limitations by either installing scrubbing equipment that cleans the emissions or using fuel with lower sulfur content. The law tied the timing of compliance to major renovations in order to give power plants a grace period in which to comply. Many power plants, however, have exploited a loophole in this law by instituting a series of "minor" renovations that, in effect, upgrade their equipment without requiring them to comply with the Clean Air Act. Some plants have cheated the system by undergoing "minor" renovations for decades.
The power companies claim that they have to resort to these underhanded measures because the cost of compliance with the Clean Air Act is too high. And if everyone else is cheating the system, why should they have to install costly sulfur dioxide scrubbers?
This cost argument falls apart upon scrutiny. Since 1977, more than 400 power plants across the country have managed to comply with the restrictions and are still making money. The sulfur dioxide scrubbing equipment has turned out to be far less expensive than the power industry naysayers claimed it would be. Many power plants have even complied with the emissions limits and reduced their operating costs by switching from high-sulfur Appalachian coal to the low-sulfur coal produced in western states such as Wyoming and Idaho. Western coal is not only cleaner than eastern coal, but also, because it is generally closer to the surface, as much as 30 percent less expensive to extract.
Clearly, the costs of compliance with the Clean Air Act can be justified, but if these companies were honest, such justifications would not have to be made. If they were honest, they would acknowledge the costs of not complying: the health costs of increased rates of asthma and lung cancer in high-emissions areas; the environmental costs of acid-scarred forests and lakes; the aesthetic costs of a haze of sulfur dioxide cutting visibility across the eastern United States to only half of what it was in pre-industrial times. When you look at the true costs you have to ask, is any cost too high for clean air? [br] Which of the following statements, if true, would provide the strongest argument for a utility company spokesman wishing to refute the arguments expressed in the passage?
选项
A、Over the last decade, the energy industry has funded an environmental initiative that has planted more than 200,000 new trees.
B、The dangers of acid rain to human health have been wildly exaggerated by environmental extremists who seek to scare the general public.
C、The specifications of the Clean Air Act, although well intentioned, in practice require power plants to adopt less efficient technologies that increase emissions of atmospheric pollutants other than sulfur dioxide that have been linked to equally serious
D、A substantial upgrade to a coal-burning power plant that includes the installation of sulfur dioxide scrubbing equipment can cost hundreds of millions of dollars, although companies can often recoup most of these costs over the following years as a result
E、The scientific data upon which the Clean Air Act was based have not been corroborated by the scientists at the Center for Atmospheric Truth, a research group funded by a consortium of energy companies.
答案
C
解析
C suggests that the specifications that the passage argues companies should follow in order to clean the air might actually have the opposite effect, and could make the air less clean. If true, this would undermine the entire argument of the passage. A and B are defenses for energy companies but do not fundamentally undermine the argument in the passage. The information presented in D probably weakens the energy industry’s argument more than it helps it. And statement E does not say that the scientific data are false, only that a group with financial ties to the energy industry (and, hence, probably biased) has not corroborated those data. C is the best answer.
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3359618.html
相关试题推荐
Tomakeupanobjectivetest,theteacherwritesaseriesofquestions,______ha
Tomakeupanobjectivetest,theteacherwritesaseriesofquestions,______ha
Tomakeupanobjectivetest,theteacherwritesaseriesofquestions,______h
He______readingsilentlyatfirst.A、usednottoB、didn’tusetoC、wasnotused
Hewas______enoughtounderstandmyquestionsfromthegesturesImade.A、intell
Tomakeupanobjectivetest,theteacherwritesaseriesofquestions,______ha
李明正在看报纸。LiMingisreadinganewspaper.
Hewas______enoughtounderstandmyquestionsfromthegesturesImade.A、intel
Ourpreferencesforcertaincolorsare______accordingtothepassage.[br]If
Theresultsofthesurveyareinterestingandthey______morequestionsthanth
随机试题
Itisoftenclaimedthatnuclearenergyissomethingwecannotdowithout.W
Heobviouslydisplaysagreat______forsomeofyourpoems.A、consentB、admiration
系统设计阶段的任务是( )。A.根据系统规划书中的功能要求,具体设计实现功能的
1982版到2014版的熊猫金银纪念币标注的重量单位都是“盎司”,1盎司等于31
以下关于信托(契约)型股权投资基金的清算说法正确的是( )A.信托(契约)型股
患者,女性,68岁。反复咳嗽、喘息20年,加重1周入院。查体:神清,口唇发绀,颈
A.免疫防御B.免疫自稳C.免疫监视功能失调D.免疫自稳功能失调E.免疫防御反应
变电运维管理规定对于影响遥控操作的缺陷,应尽快安排处理,处理前后均应及时告知(
1968年,美国著名的心理学家罗森塔尔做了一个实验。他从小学每个年级中抽出部分学
审计时,审查书面资料的技术有()。A.核对法 B.详查法 C.审阅法 D
最新回复
(
0
)