首页
登录
职称英语
Economist: Paying extra for fair-trade coffee—coffee labeled with the Fairtrade
Economist: Paying extra for fair-trade coffee—coffee labeled with the Fairtrade
游客
2024-01-12
20
管理
问题
Economist: Paying extra for fair-trade coffee—coffee labeled with the Fairtrade logo—is intended to help poor farmers, because they receive a higher price for the fair-trade coffee they grow. But this practice may hurt more farmers in developing nations than it helps. By raising average prices for coffee, it encourages more coffee to be produced than consumers want to buy. This lowers prices for non-fair-trade coffee and thus lowers profits for non-fair-trade coffee farmers.
To evaluate the strength of the economist’s argument, it would be most helpful to know which of the following?
选项
A、Whether there is a way of alleviating the impact of the increased average prices for coffee on non-fair-trade coffee farmers’ profits
B、What proportion of coffee farmers in developing nations produce fair-trade coffee
C、Whether many coffee farmers in developing nations also derive income from other kinds of farming
D、Whether consumers should pay extra for fair-trade coffee if doing so lowers profits for non-fair-trade coffee farmers
E、How fair-trade coffee farmers in developing nations could be helped without lowering profits for non-fair-trade coffee farmers
答案
B
解析
Argument Evaluation
Situation Poor farmers receive higher prices for fair-trade coffee. But paying extra for fair-trade coffee lowers prices for non-fair-trade coffee and thus lowers profits for non-fair-trade coffee farmers
Reasoning What would be most helpful to know to evaluate how well the economist’s observations support the conclusion that buying fair-trade coffee hurts more farmers in developing nations than it helps? The economist suggests that buying fair-trade coffee benefits farmers who grow it because they receive higher prices, but that it hurts non-fair-trade coffee farmers by reducing their profits. So to knew whether the practice hurts more farmers in developing nations than it helps, it would be helpful to know whether developing nations have more farmers who produce non-fair-trade coffee than produce fair-trade coffee.
A Even if there were some potential way of alleviating the negative impact from buying fair-trade coffee on non-fair-trade coffee farmers, it still could be that the practice hurts more developing-nation farmers than it helps. Alleviating the negative impact does not entail that there is no negative impact.
B Correct. If fewer than half of these farmers produce fair-trade coffee, then the economist’s observations do suggest that buying fair-trade coffee hurts more coffee farmers in developing nations than it helps. But if more than half do, those observations suggest the contrary.
C Although knowing this could be helpful in determining how intensely many farmers are economically affected by people buying fair-trade coffee, it is not helpful in determining whether more farmers are hurt than are helped.
D The argument’s conclusion is only about the economic impact of buying fair-trade coffee, not about how consumers should or should not respond to that impact.
E Knowing how the fair-trade coffee farmers could potentially be helped without hurting the other coffee farmers is irrelevant to assessing whether the practice of buying fair-trade coffee hurts more developing -nation farmers than it helps.
The correct answer is B.
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3357381.html
相关试题推荐
Caffeine,thestimulantincoffee,hasbeencalled"themostwidelyusedpsy
Caffeine,thestimulantincoffee,hasbeencalled"themostwidelyusedpsy
Caffeine,thestimulantincoffee,hasbeencalled"themostwidelyusedpsy
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefre
AneconomistconcludedthatKreggCompanydeliberatelydiscriminatedagainstpeo
随机试题
DuringMcDonald’searlyyearsFrenchfriesweremadefromscratcheveryday.
Somemarriagesseemtocollapsesosuddenlythatyou’dneedacrystalballt
关于别嘌醇药理作用的描述,错误的是()A:抑制黄嘌呤氧化酶,阻止次黄嘌呤和黄嘌
按试验确定级配碎石的目标级配与最佳含水率,应以现场施工的压实标准成型试件,进行C
根治折返性室上性心动过速首选的方法是A.外科手术 B.射频消融术 C.长期服
下列各项,不属传染病基本特征的是A.有病原体 B.有感染后免疫性 C.
心脏病患者疑为甲亢时,慎用的实验是A.TRH兴奋实验 B.I摄取实验 C.T
某地上2层汽车库,耐火等级为一级,总停车位300个。对该汽车库进行防火检查,下列
银行承兑汇票的承兑银行,应当按照票面金额向出票人收取()的手续费。A:千分之一
某双绕组变压器的额定容量为15000kVA,额定变比为121/10.5kV,△P
最新回复
(
0
)