首页
登录
职称英语
Removing DamsP1: In the last century, many of the dams in the United States wer
Removing DamsP1: In the last century, many of the dams in the United States wer
游客
2024-01-03
47
管理
问题
Removing Dams
P1: In the last century, many of the dams in the United States were built for water diversion, agriculture, factory watermills, and other purposes that allowed farming on lands that would otherwise be too dry, with low-cost hydroelectric power generation being a very significant side benefit. Building these dams was rather labor-intensive, which created jobs for workers and stimulated regional economic development. But those opposed to large dams can marshal a sobering array of criticisms based on those already built, which have provided some benefits but have without exception destroyed river environments and the human communities that depend on them.
P2: Many, perhaps most, of the more than 90,000 dams in the country are now obsolete, expensive, and unsafe, and were built with no consideration of the environmental costs. As operating licenses come up for renewal in 1999, habitat restoration to original stream flows will be among the options considered. As these dams age and decay, they can also become public safety hazards, presenting a failure risk and a dangerous nuisance. Worse still, with the growth of the American population, more people are moving into risky areas. Dams that once could have failed without major repercussions are now upstream of cities and development. In 1998, the Army Corps announced that it would no longer be building large dams. In the few remaining sites where dams might be built, public opposition is so great that getting approval for projects is unlikely.
P3: For many years, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service had advocated the removal of the Edwards Dam, which was built in 1837 on the Kennebec River in Augusta, Maine, to ease navigation and generate electricity. The Kennebec River was once home to all ten species of migratory fish native to Maine, along with several thriving commercial fisheries. Damming the river not only transformed the natural landscape, but it also prevented migration of salmon, shad, sturgeon, and other fish species up the river.
In 1999, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) refused the renewal of the dam license due to excessive negative environmental impact, and the dam was removed, freeing a 17-mile stretch of the Kennebec River that had been submerged for 162 years. P4: The cost of keeping outdated hydroelectric equipment running decades after it was installed or upgrading dam safety systems may not be worth it. This was proven true on the Elwha River in the Olympic National Park in Washington when an extraordinarily rich salmon habitat was being disrupted by an outdated hydroelectric plant. Before dams were built on the Elwha River, 400,000 salmon returned each year to spawn, but that number dropped to fewer than 3,000 after dams were put up. Once the hydroelectric power generating capacities of the dams had outlived their useful lives, the importance of this salmon habitat necessitated the removal of the dams on the Elwha River. Simply removing the dams will not restore the salmon, however. Where 50-kilogram king salmon once fought their way up waterfalls to lay their eggs in gravel beds, there are now only concrete walls holding back still water and deep beds of muddy deposits.
P5: When the negative environmental effects outweigh the benefits, a dam may be considered for removal. The Hetch Hetchy Dam, whose construction was one of the first major defeats of the nascent American environmental movement, was approved in 1913 to assist earthquake-ravaged San Francisco. Environmentalists and nature lovers, who said the valley’s beauty surpassed even Yosemite Valley’s, have constantly fought for its removal. They claim that restoring Hetch Hetchy Valley could reclaim an area that is half the size of Yosemite Valley and nearly identical in terms of beauty. Revenue and increased local spending from tourism could offset some or all of the losses from removing the dam. This problem can be thought of as appraising the relative value of two scarce resources, water and space, in Yosemite National Park.
P6: How does one weigh the many different economic, cultural, and aesthetic considerations for removing or not removing these dams? Do certain interests, such as the rights of native people or the continued existence of native species of fish or wildlife, take precedence over economic factors, or should this be a utilitarian calculation of the greatest good for the greatest number? And does that number include only humans, or do other species count as well?
P4: ■ The cost of keeping outdated hydroelectric equipment running decades after it was installed or upgrading dam safety systems may not be worth it. ■ This was proven true on the Elwha River in the Olympic National Park in Washington when an extraordinarily rich salmon habitat was being disrupted by an outdated hydroelectric plant. ■ Before dams were built on the Elwha River, 400,000 salmon returned each year to spawn, but that number dropped to fewer than 3,000 after dams were put up. ■ Once the hydroelectric power generating capacities of the dams had outlived their useful lives, the importance of this salmon habitat necessitated the removal of the dams on the Elwha River. Simply removing the dams will not restore the salmon, however. Where 50-kilogram king salmon once fought their way up waterfalls to lay their eggs in gravel beds, there are now only concrete walls holding back still water and deep beds of muddy deposits. [br] What is the role of paragraph 6 in the passage?
选项
A、To propose a method for deciding whether a given dam should be removed
B、To emphasize the complexity of the issues involved in deciding what should be done about dams
C、To suggest that the recent tendency not to build new dams may be wrong
D、To sum up the points made earlier in the passage about the advantages and disadvantages of removing dams
答案
B
解析
【修辞目的题】第六段第一句提问应该如何去从经济、文化和美观等各种不同的角度去衡量是否要拆除这些大坝,以反问的方式来强调拆不拆除大坝是一件非常复杂的事情。涉及多个影响因素。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3328759.html
相关试题推荐
CITYARCHIVESAnineteenth-centurydocumentsBmapsCpersonalpapersDphotog
CITYARCHIVESAnineteenth-centurydocumentsBmapsCpersonalpapersDphotog
CITYARCHIVESAnineteenth-centurydocumentsBmapsCpersonalpapersDphotog
CITYARCHIVESAnineteenth-centurydocumentsBmapsCpersonalpapersDphotog
TheDinee,aNativeAmerican(people)ofthesouthwesternUnitedStates,were(o
[originaltext]Inthe18thcenturyFrencheconomistsprotestedtheexcessive
(Itwas)the(splitof)elevensouthern(states)fromtheUnionin1861that(le
Duringthenineteenthcenturythemoleculartheoryofmatterwasdeveloped,(whi
TheMedicareprogram(wasestablished)in1965to(helping)elderlyUnitedState
TheAtlanticcable,whichbegan(tooperating)in1866,1inkedtheUnitedStates
随机试题
Whenyoubuysomethingandpayforitwithbillsorcoins,youarepaying(1
TheDoubleNatureofLiteraryTranslationⅠ.Introduction
PASSAGETWOBytransplanting“anti-freeze”geneintootherspecies.根据题目中的extremely
“UN1372动物纤维或植物纤维,烧过的、湿的或潮的”在“危险货物品名表”中的
女性,50岁。右乳外上象限包块3个月。查体:右乳外上象限可触及一3cm×2cm肿
共用题干 (一)资料2012年4月,某审计组对甲公司2011年度财务收支情况进
细胞外液的离子主要为A.钾离子 B.镁离子 C.钠离子 D.钙离子 E.
一住店客人未付房钱即想离开旅馆去车站。旅馆服务员揪住他不让走,并打报警电话。客人
根据《建设工程工程量清单计价规范》(GB50500—2008),若因非承包人原因
下列选项中,不属于低层或多层民用建筑的是()。A.建筑高度26m的3层住宅建筑
最新回复
(
0
)