Those who fight against alcohol sales say the extra tax comes at a cost. Lee

游客2023-12-31 26

问题 Those who fight against alcohol sales say the extra tax comes at a cost. Lee Miller, a leader of Angelina Citizens for a Better Community, the group vowing to defeat the measure, points to data from the State of Texas showing that for every US$1 in revenue the state received from alcohol, US$9 is paid out for expenses like treatment for alcohol abuse, law enforcement services and motor vehicle crashes. "This will not benefit us as a community, " Mr. Miller said. "It costs us more money in expenses and in the lives of our children."
Mr. Miller, who does not drink, says he is concerned that if the vote passes, his 12-year-old daughter and 14-year-old son will have easier access to alcohol.
David Hatch, the political strategist of Angelina County Citizens for Responsible Business (ACCRB), argues that Mr. Miller’s cost revenue figures paint an inaccurate picture because they do not consider the additional sales taxes from alcohol purchases, only revenue from alcohol excise taxes, the bulk of which flow to the state.
Oscar Dillahunty, a 69-year-old, one-time beer distributor who hired Mr. Hatch and started ACCRB, has estimated that the county could rack up at least US$15 million in annual beer sales alone, which would translate into US$225, 000 in sales tax revenue for Lufkin and US$75, 000 for the county. He says his estimate is based on sales in a similar county in Mississippi, where he previously owned a beer distributor.
Many officials in towns and counties that recently went wet say they have not seen an increase in reported crime or drunken driving. Steven Cagle, the city manager in Duncanville, said the town had not devolved into "Drunkenville, " as church groups claimed it would.
Three police chiefs — David Walker of Fort Payne, Tex., Benny Womack of Albertville, Ala., and Eddie Phillips of East Ridge, Term. — all say they have not seen any increase in law enforcement problems since alcohol sales began in 2004.
But just as the feared public mayhem wrought by alcohol abuse often fails to materialize, the economic prosperity is often absent, too. In Albertville, Ala., the Rev. Willis Kelly, who preaches at Douglas First Baptist Church, says he is still waiting for the town’s financial boom. "The folks that wanted it to go wet campaigned on the idea that it would bring in money to build a new school, " Mr. Kelly said. "Last year, they collected only a little over US$100, 000 in extra taxes. That wouldn’t even buy toilet paper."
Mr. Kelly says that since the vote in June, no new restaurants have opened in Albertville, a town of 18, 000 people 65 miles from Birmingham, and only one of the two grocery stores in town opted to sell beer and wine.
Jon Howard, director of finance for Albertville, would not confirm Mr. Kelly’s tax numbers, and Mayor Carl Pruett declined to comment on the town’s economy.
In Lufkin, where in recent years the economy has been surging without the help of alcohol sales, some citizens just want their town to be a bit more like the rest of the country and a little less Bible Belt. "This is the 21st century, " said Ernest Rowe, a 70-year-old retired forest worker. "I just want to be able to buy my case of Coors Light, come home and pop open a cold one." [br] Mr. Hatch shares the opinions of______.

选项 A、Carl Pruett
B、Ernest Rowe
C、Benny Womack
D、Oscar Dillahunty

答案 D

解析比较判断。第三段Mr．Hatch的观点是Mr．Miller’s cost revenue不准确，只计算了消费税，没有考虑the additional sales taxes from alcohol purchases；第四段Oscar Dillahunty的观点是该县啤酒年销售额至少US$15 million，给Lufkin带来税收US$225，000，县财政US$75，000；第六段Benny Womack的观点是they have not seen any increase in law enforcement problems since alcohol sales began in 2004，驳斥了Mr． Miller的观点；Carl Pruett出现在第九段，作为镇长，他拒绝评论该镇的经济；Ernest Rowe在最后一段，他只想回家喝一杯冰镇啤酒。把Mr．Hatch的观点与四个选项提到的人两相比较，只有Oscar Dillahunty与之接近，二者都认为酒类销售可以增加财政收入。【知识拓展】比较判断属于scanning，阅读时把题目涉及的人名和观点(尤其是关键词)勾画出来，便于快速比较、提高阅读速度与理解的准确性。

转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3320480.html

相关试题推荐

随机试题

最新回复(0)

Those who fight against alcohol sales say the extra tax comes at a cost. Lee

TheblunderofArgentina’sgoaliecostthemthegameinthematchagainstBrazi

Thevoterswereoverwhelminglyagainstthecandidatehisproposalscalledforhi

Inhisrecentspeech,thechancellorwarnedagainstcomplacencytothestrength