首页
登录
职称英语
With a gnashing of teeth, the employment minister Chris Grayling backed down
With a gnashing of teeth, the employment minister Chris Grayling backed down
游客
2023-12-22
34
管理
问题
With a gnashing of teeth, the employment minister Chris Grayling backed down as companies shied away from his unpaid work scheme that threatened young people’ s already meagre weekly benefit of 53. 45. Protests and a Twitter storm against unpaid shelf-stacking alarmed Tesco into paying the minimum wage and guaranteeing jobs: a brilliant result. UK Uncut exposing Barclays’ tax avoidance has finally led HMRC to act, so as St Paul’s Occupy protesters move on, don’t say protest is pointless.
However, objections by bishops were bootless as the welfare reform bill passed, barely amended. The government revels in a majority heartily supporting its ? 18bn benefit cuts. A drip-drip of scrounger stories did the heavy lifting, so most people have no idea what brutality is to be done in their name. The BBC has failed to inform the nation, bolstering the "scrounger" narrative with ill-timed documentaries on the workshy by Panorama. With dole claimants rising towards 3 million, and 6. 3 million in all seeking work or longer hours, the government has devised a strange sociology suggesting an epidemic of laziness, ignoring the worst depression since the 1930s.
But has it finally gone too far? When the public discovers what’s happening, attitudes may change. Remember Gordon Brown’s catastrophic miscalculation in abolishing the 10p tax rate for the lowest paid; using the money to bribe middle earners by cutting their taxes backfired badly. Fickle voters can’t be relied on to be selfish all the time, so when people hear what’s about to happen, they may react in the same way.
On 6 April, low-paid working couples with children will lose a colossal ? 3,870 in tax credits from a typical income of ? 17,000. Where previously someone in the family had to work 16 hours to qualify, now they must work 24 hours a week or lose tax credits. But what if no extra hours are available? Hundreds of thousands of households will be caught in this trap, with 470,000 children. Most already want longer hours. TUC research says 3 million part-timers seek full-time jobs; Usdaw, the shopworkers’ union, finds 78% of its part-timers can’t get extra hours. Government figures for people getting jobs forget to say most are part-time. Nor do they proclaim the severe punishment about to fall on families failing to work 24 hours. Oddly, the victims are the very people Conservatives praise—working couples with children, struggling to stay off the dole. Will this enormous drop in incomes fall below the political radar—or will voters discover and be shocked?
Everyone asks for extra hours: in Liverpool there are 8. 5 unemployed for every vacancy. Without more hours, they expect to lose about ? 300 a month in tax credits. But just as existing workers struggle for crucial extra hours, the Department for Work and Pensions puts the unemployed to work for free at shelf-stacking and cleaning— 34,200 young people have been put on unpaid work experience so far, with weak evidence it finds them jobs. Jonathan Porte, of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, finds the ministers’ claim that 50% leave benefits compares poorly with the 60% who leave jobseeker’ s allowance anyway within three months with no scheme.
Conditions have always been attached to benefits—the "no fifth option of continued full benefit" of Labour’s New Deal, for example. Compulsion for the unemployed to join programmes seems reasonable so long as schemes are high quality with a good chance of leading to jobs. Until now, great care was taken not to displace real jobs through free labour for large companies able to pay minimum wage. Work experience for the young has drawn all the flak, but the "mandatory work activity" programme forces adults to work up to 30 hours a week over a month for free, or lose benefit. The DWP’s own assessment shows those mandated into unpaid work are more likely to be from an ethnic minority and disabled than other unemployed people.
So on the one hand the DWP imposes draconian cuts on families who can’t find 24 hours a week paid work, yet at the same time puts tens of thousands of free labourers into their workplaces, making those extra hours ever harder to find. This week I had a run-in with the former social security secretary Peter Lilley on Radio 5 Live as he tried to defend the government’s schemes, but it was plain he had forgotten the essential ingredients in Project Work, his 1996 initiative, which I praised at the time: people were paid extra above their benefits, and worked for charities and community programmes to avoid displacing other workers—and compulsion was applied at a time of rising employment, with a good chance of leading to real jobs. None of these principles applies now. Worst of all, depriving existing staff of extra hours of work will contribute to families losing their tax credits. Unemployment pay had dropped in 35 years from 17% of average earnings to just 10% : now it’s falling far faster.
April will bring plenty of Nick Clegg’s promised social mobility—but it will all be downwards. Raising tax thresholds does nothing for these people, as hundreds of thousands of children are pushed into poverty by a monumental drop in family income. This cut denies everything the government says about "making work pay" and supporting couples. Politically, will this finally shock enough voters? [br] It can be concluded from the passage that the author’s attitude is______.
选项
A、objective and eclectic
B、critical and argumentative
C、supportive and persuasive
D、optimistic and sympathetic
答案
B
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3295338.html
相关试题推荐
Theprimeministerwas________toseverecriticismaftertheeconomyhadcontract
Theminister’sunwisefinancialstrategy________ahighrateofinflationthatse
HonorableMinisters,YourExcellencies,LadiesandGentlemen,Itisagreat
[originaltext]Everyoneknowsaboutunemployment.ButmillionsofworkingAm
[originaltext]Everyoneknowsaboutunemployment.ButmillionsofworkingAm
[originaltext]Everyoneknowsaboutunemployment.ButmillionsofworkingAm
AboutthousandAmericantroopsarebasedinJapan.MinisterKoizumisentJapanes
AboutthousandAmericantroopsarebasedinJapan.MinisterKoizumisentJapanes
AboutthousandAmericantroopsarebasedinJapan.MinisterKoizumisentJapanes
AboutthousandAmericantroopsarebasedinJapan.MinisterKoizumisentJapanes
随机试题
设计者和匠师们因地制宜,自出心裁,修建成功的园林当然各各不同。可是苏州各个园林在不同之中有个共同点,似乎设计者和匠师们一致追求的是:务必使游览者无论站在
工程监理单位监理工作人员在开展费用监理工作的过程中,应遵循的依据包括( )。A
中缀表达式A-(B+C/D)*E的后缀形式是()。A.AB-C+D/E* B.
鉴别腹股沟斜疝、直疝,下列哪种检查最准确()A.平卧时肿物消失为直疝,否则
肝、脾、淋巴结肿大伴颅骨缺损,可能为A.黏多糖病 B.皮肤黏膜淋巴结综合征
下面出自龚自珍《说天寿山》第三节的是()A.最多珍花灵草,枝态不类。桃芬李葩,映
构成商业银行有效管理控制风险的外部保障的要素包括()。A.市场约束 B.
因上市公司减少股本导致投资者及其一致行动人取得被收购公司的股份达到5%及之后变动
甲在证券市场上陆续买入力扬股份公司的股票,持股达6%时才公告,被证券监督管理机构
某工程由于操作者振捣疏漏,造成一起混凝土质量事故,若该事故按事故责任分类应属于(
最新回复
(
0
)