首页
登录
职称英语
The advantage of associating the birth of democracy with the Mayflower Compa
The advantage of associating the birth of democracy with the Mayflower Compa
游客
2023-12-07
24
管理
问题
The advantage of associating the birth of democracy with the Mayflower Compact is that it is easy to do so. The public believes a simple explanation that on November 11, 1620, when the compact was approved, a cornerstone of American democracy was laid. Certainly it makes it easier on schoolchildren. Making the start of democracy in 1620 relieves students of the responsibility of knowing what happened in the hundred some years before, from the arrival of the Santa Maria to the landing of the Mayflower.
Surely, the compact demonstrated the Englishman’s striking capacity for self-government. And in affirming the principle of majority rule, the Pilgrims showed how far they had come from the days when the king’s whim was law and nobody dared say otherwise.
But the emphasis on the compact is misplaced. Scholarly research in the last century indicates that the compact had nothing to do with the development of the self-government in America. In truth, the Mayflower Compact was no more a cornerstone of American democracy than the Pilgrim hut was the foundation of American architecture. As Samuel Morison so emphatically put it, American democracy "was not born in the cabin of the Mayflower".
The Pilgrims indeed are miscast as the heroes of American democracy. They spurned democracy and would have been shocked to see themselves help up as its defenders. George Willison, regarded as one of the most careful students of the Pilgrims, states that "the merest glance at the history of Plymouth" shows that they were not democrats.
The mythmakers would have us believe that even if the Pilgrims themselves weren’t democratic, the Mayflower Compact itself was. But in fact the compact was expressly designed to check freedom, not promote it. The Pilgrim governor and historian, William Bradford, from whom we have gotten nearly all of the information there is about the Pilgrims, frankly conceded as much. Bradford wrote that the purpose of the compact was to control traitors aboard the Mayflower who were threatening to go their own way when the ship reached land. Because the Pilgrims had decided to settle in an area outside the jurisdiction of their royal patent, some aboard the Mayflower had hinted that upon landing they would "use their own liberty, for none had power to command them". Under the terms of the compact, they couldn’t; the compact required all who lived in the colony to "promise all due submission and obedience" to it.
Moreover, despite the compact’s mention of majority rule, the Pilgrim fathers had no intention of turning over the colony’s government to the people. Plymouth was to be ruled by the elite. And the elite wasn’t shameful in the least about advancing its claims to superiority. When the Mayflower Compact was signed, the elite signed first. The second rank consisted of the "goodmen" and the bottom four servants. No women or children signed. [br] According to Para. 5, which one is correct?
选项
A、The compact’s real purpose was to keep the Pilgrims’ freedom under control.
B、William Bradford agreed with what mythmakers said.
C、The compact allowed Pilgrims to use their own liberty upon landing.
D、The Mayflower Compact itself was democratic.
答案
A
解析
事实细节题。可从选项入手,逐一解答。[A]“协议的真正目的是要控制清教徒的自由”,这与该段第二句话的意思一致,所以正确;[B]“威廉·布雷福德同意神话编造者所说的”,这与该段第三句话的意思相矛盾,该句中的conceded as much是指承认了“协议是控制自由而不是促进自由的”,所以不正确;[C]“协议允许清教徒在登陆后使用自由权”,这正与协议的目的相反。从该段的倒数第一句中的they couldn’t(use their own liberty)可以得知,所以不正确;[D]“‘五月花号协议’是民主的”,这与该段的观点相矛盾,从该段的第一、二句话可知,这是误导人民的神话,也正是作者所批驳的观点,所以不正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3252422.html
相关试题推荐
Whichofthefollowingisanadvantageofhotels?[br][originaltext]W:Wecont
Whichofthefollowingisanadvantageofhotels?[originaltext]W:Wecontinuen
WatchingMoviesinEnglishI.OnegreatadvantageofEng
WatchingMoviesinEnglishI.OnegreatadvantageofEng
WatchingMoviesinEnglishI.OnegreatadvantageofEng
WatchingMoviesinEnglishI.OnegreatadvantageofEng
AdvantagesandDisadvantagesofStudyingAbroadInthefirstpartof
In______,asmallgroupofPuritanssailedfromPlymouthintheMayflower,andf
TheadvantageofassociatingthebirthofdemocracywiththeMayflowerCompa
TheadvantageofassociatingthebirthofdemocracywiththeMayflowerCompa
随机试题
IcametoAfricawithonepurpose:Iwantedtoseetheworldoutsidetheper
滤波器按照阻抗特性可以分为()A.单调谐滤波器 B.高通滤波器
患者20岁,1小时前外伤,自觉上前牙变短,要求治疗。查:左上1牙冠比邻牙短3mm
腕关节量诊中,正常桡骨茎突比耻骨茎突低A.0.5cm B.1.0cm C
不考虑其他因素,就单项事项而言,以下符合管理层收购上市公司规定的条件的有()。
根据以下有关科技创新的材料。回答问题。为了响应国家关于“创建创新型国家”的号召。
下列哪种中药既能杀虫止痒、燥湿,又能温肾壮阳A:蟾酥B:蛇床子C:地肤子D
在建设社会主义市场经济体制和小康社会的历史条件下,预防、制止和惩治违法犯罪活动尤
期货合约标准化的好处有()。A.使期货合约的连续买卖更加便利 B.使期货合约
甲为要回30万元赌债,将乙扣押,但2天后乙仍无还款意思。甲等5人将乙押到一处山崖
最新回复
(
0
)