首页
登录
职称英语
One of the obvious problems with predicting the future effects of climate ch
One of the obvious problems with predicting the future effects of climate ch
游客
2023-12-05
36
管理
问题
One of the obvious problems with predicting the future effects of climate change is that they haven’t happened. This makes climate studies highly dependent on models, which invariably and unavoidably make simplifying assumptions. This means that using their results to say anything of practical import needs care and caveats, both of which can often be in short supply, or stripped out to make a point.
However, it is now ever more possible for studies of climate change to look at the past, not the future. The 20th century saw a fair amount of warming, and it is sometimes possible to compare what this warming did and didn’t do with what future warming might or might not do. This is what a paper published in Nature this week does in an attempt to re-examine, and perhaps close down, long-running debates about malaria and climate change.
Both the malaria parasite and the mosquitoes which spread it respond to temperature and moisture. Understanding those responses makes it possible to model what changes in climate might mean to the incidence of the disease. Such models have suggested that in a warmer world the area subject to endemic malaria would increase, perhaps quite a lot, though some places would see a reduction due to increased aridity. The caveats here include noting that the climate models can make no great claims to accuracy at the regional level and that such an approach does almost nothing to deal with changes in land use, wealth and public health programs.
One of the main thrusts of the new Nature paper is to see how much of what happened to the spread of malaria in the 20th century can be explained by what happened to the climate. The answer, according to Peter Gething of Oxford University and his colleagues, is not much. They conclude that claims that a warming climate has led to more widespread disease and death due to malaria are largely at odds with the evidence, which shows the areas effected shrinking, and the size of the effect shrinking too. Increases in the spread and severity of the disease burden foreseen over the next 40 years by the biological models are far smaller than the decreases in comparable measures seen over the past century.
The second tack of their argument is to compare the sort of effect seen in biology-based models of where malaria might spread with both models of and data on the effects direct intervention against the disease can have. Again the effects due to climate are small, even negligible, compared with the effects that interventions have achieved already and might achieve in decades to come. The marginal areas where climate might enlarge the area at risk are also, the article argues, the areas where the greatest declines in transmission have recently been seen thanks to increased intervention.
The conclusion is clear. People who are thinking about what to do about malaria should bear in mind that the biological basis of its distribution may change in a warmer world. Those thinking about the overall danger that climate change represents should not spend their time worrying about its impact on malaria.
Is there a wider conclusion to draw about computer models such as those that underlay frightening statements about malaria in a climate-changed world? Perhaps; but like the models themselves, it comes with caveats.
Scientists tend to model what can be modeled, and natural scientists, in particular, tend to prefer models that incorporate at least some aspects of the underlying processes which they are interested in, rather than working purely on empirical correlations. This means that if you search the scientific literature for approaches to the future, you will tend to find answers based on natural processes. If other knowledge suggests that natural processes aren’t the most important aspect of the problem at hand, then it’s a good idea to look at the models with that provision in the forefront of your mind.
The other vital lesson is that the caveats matter. Pretty much every paper presenting a biology-based model of malaria’s dependence on climate contains a warning that changes in economy, technology and society matter too, and aren’t in the model. To transmit the model’s results without important caveats is reckless.
If one is going to be optimistic about the future of malaria, one might also, with caution, be optimistic about the future of assessments of climate change. Things can, over time, get better, especially when the record of what has happened to date gets taken seriously. They will do so quicker if people accept both the usefulness and limits of models of the future, as well as the appeal of models of the past. [br] The major defect of the current climate-study models lies in their______.
选项
A、simplifying assumptions
B、comparative methodology
C、arbitrary assertions
D、heavy dependence on future
答案
C
解析
细节题。第一段第二、三句指出,气候研究严重依赖于模型,而模型不可避免地会做一些简化的假设。这就意味着要想利用模型得出的结果来说明实际的问题,我们需要谨慎并且附加说明,而这些防止误解的说明往往被忽略,由此可以推断,当前气候研究模型的缺陷不是简化的假设,而是简单地从假设中推出结论,故[C]为正确答案,同时排除[A]和[D]。第一段第一句指出,以未来为导向的气候研究是有问题的,但问题不在于其比较方法,而在于它们尚未发生,故排除[B]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3245394.html
相关试题推荐
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Language-basedlearningdisabilitiesareproblemswithage-appropriateread
Advancesinscienceandtechnologyhelpedsolvingmanyproblems.However,th
EndtheUniversityasWeKnowIt1.ProblemsconfrontingAme
EndtheUniversityasWeKnowIt1.ProblemsconfrontingAme
随机试题
AlthoughtheCivilWarwasofficiallyover,thehostilityandtensionbetweenbl
设某国某年国民收入经济数据如表1-2所示 (1)用支出法计算GDP。(2
下列属于表见代理的构成要件的有()。A.行为人既没有代理权,也没有令人相信其有
药物的LD50和ED50值如下所示,哪种药物最有临床意义()。A.LD505
若6位同学站成一排,其中甲、乙两位同学相邻站立,则不同的站法有()种。A.
共用题干 患儿,男,7岁。午后突然发生腹痛、呕吐,面色发白,四肢无力,呕吐物为
一住店客人未付房钱即想离开旅馆去车站。旅馆服务员揪住他不让走,并打报警电话。客人
女,26岁,甲状腺区右侧可扪及一个0.5cm×0.7cm结节,无触痛。 实验室
关于市场定位的说法,错误的是()。A.市场定位是企业根据竞争者产品所在区域,
(2016年真题)某工程施工至某月底,经统计分析得:已完工程计划费用1800万元
最新回复
(
0
)