首页
登录
职称英语
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world
游客
2023-08-06
58
管理
问题
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world forever? Or is it already bumping into limits? In his 2011 book The Beginning of Infinity physicist David Deutsch made the case for boundlessness. When I asked him about consciousness, he replied: "I think nothing worth understanding will always remain a mystery. And consciousness seems apparently worth understanding. "
At a meeting I just attended in Switzerland, "The Mystery of Human Consciousness," another famous British physicist, Martin Rees, challenged Deutsch’s optimism. In that essay Rees calls The Beginning of Infinity "provocative and excellent" but disputes Deutsch’s central claim that science is boundless. Science "will hit the buffers (缓冲区) at some point," Rees warns.
There are two reasons why this might happen. The optimistic one is that we clean up and understand certain areas (such as atomic physics) to the point that there’s no more to say. A second, more worrying possibility is that we’ll reach the limits of what our brains can grasp. There might be concepts, crucial to a full understanding of physical reality. Efforts to understand very complex systems, such as our own brains, might well be the first to hit such limits.
Perhaps complex collectives of atoms, whether brains or electronic machines, can never know all there is to know about themselves.
The riddle of consciousness is a synecdoche for the riddle of humanity. What we, really? For most of our history, religion has given us the answer. Most modern scientists reject these religious explanations, but they cannot agree on an alternative. They have proposed a bewildering variety of answers to the question of what we really are.
Science will never resolve these disagreements and converge on a single, true theory of what we are, for two reasons. One is that we will never have a "consciousness meter," an objective means of measuring consciousness in non-human things. The other is that we are too varying, too creative, to be captured by a single theory. Science itself keeps transforming us. with technologies as diverse as brain implants, genetic therapy and ideas as diverse as queer theory and integrated information theory. To be human means to be a work in progress.
Deutsch’s claim that science is infinite also has a contradiction at its core. He wants science to solve the deepest mysteries, like consciousness, and yet to have more mysteries to solve, forever. That is a radical assertion about the structure of nature, which to my mind reflects wishful thinking rather than hardheaded realism.
Deutsch is both wrong and right. He is wrong that science can solve every mystery, and especially consciousness. We will never understand, once and for all, who we are. But Deutsch is right that science is potentially infinite, if infinite means never-ending. It is precisely because we can never achieve total self-knowledge that we will keep seeking it forever. [br] Which of the following statements may David Deutsch agree with?
选项
A、The case study of physics should be unlimited.
B、The scientific mysteries are worth understanding.
C、The puzzle of consciousness will be worked out.
D、Science will finally hit a bottleneck somewhere.
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/2901895.html
相关试题推荐
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—know
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—know
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—know
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings-knowled
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings-knowled
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—know
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—kno
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—kno
[originaltext]Givingagoodpresentationisallaboutthesimplethings—kno
TheAlzheimer’sAssociationandtheNationalAllianceforCaregivingestimate
随机试题
AccordingtoagroupcalledtheVoicesFoundation,everyonehasasingingvo
[originaltext]W:John,haveyouchosenaphysicaleducationclassyetforthis
甲公司属于增值税一般纳税人,2013年1月1日,甲公司应收账款的借方余额为300
下列不属于多肽类抗生素的是()A:去甲万古霉素 B:利奈唑胺 C:多黏菌素B
个体品德的核心部分是( )。A.道德认识 B.道德情感 C.道德意志 D
形盛气衰的表现是A.体胖能食,肌肉坚实 B.体胖食少,神疲乏力 C.形瘦能食
哪种中药有解毒、止痛、开窍醒神的功效A.硫黄B.硼砂C.蟾酥D.常山E.明矾
某通信项目2010年初投入资金150万元,2011年初又投入100万元,项目计算
仓库成为生产和消费领域中物资集散的中心环节,其功能已不单纯是保管、储存。从现代物
关于管道安装现场条件的表述,正确的是()。A.管道组成件及管道支承件等已检
最新回复
(
0
)