首页
登录
职称英语
Who Lives? Who Dies? Who Decides?A)Some have called it a Ri
Who Lives? Who Dies? Who Decides?A)Some have called it a Ri
游客
2023-07-05
35
管理
问题
Who Lives? Who Dies? Who Decides?
A)Some have called it a Right to Die case. Others have labeled it a Right to Live case. One group of advocates has called for "death with dignity." Others have responded accusingly, "euthanasia".
B)At the center of the latest controversy about life and death, medicine and law, is a seventy-eight-year-old Massachusetts man whose existence hangs on a court order.
C)On one point, everyone agrees: Earle Spring is not the man he used to be. Once a strapping outdoorsman, he is now called senile by many, and mentally incompetent by the courts. He is, at worst, a member of living dead; at best, a shriveled version of his former self.
D)For more than two years, since his physical and then mental health began to deteriorate , Earle Spring has been kept alive by spending five hours on a kidney dialysis machine three times a week. Since January 1979, his family has pleaded to have him removed from the life-support system.
E)They believe deeply that he Earle Spring who was would not want to live as the Earle Spring who is. They believe they are advocates for the right to die in peace.
F)In the beginning, the court agrees. Possibly for the first time, they reeled last month in favor of withdrawing medical care from an elderly patient whose mind had deteriorated. The dialysis was stopped.
G)But then, in a sudden intervention, an outside nurse and doctor visited Earle Spring and testified that he was alert enough to "make a weak expression of his desire to live." And so the treatments were resumed.
H)Now, while the courts are waiting for new and more thorough evidence about Spring’ s mental state, the controversy rages about legal procedures; no judge ever visited Spring, no psychiatrist ever testified. And even more important, we are again forced to determine one person’ s right to die or to live.
I)This case makes the Karen Ann Quinlan story seem simple in comparison. Quinlan today hangs onto her "life" long after her "plug was pulled." But when the New Jersey court heard that case, Quinlan had no will. She had suffered brain death by any definition.
J)The Spring story is different. He is neither competent nor comatose. He lives in a gray area of consciousness. So the questions also range over the gray area of our consciences.
K)What should the relationship be between mental and physical treatment? Should we treat the incompetent as aggressively as the competent? Should we order heart surgery for one senile citizen? Should we take another off a kidney machine? Who is to decide?
L)Until recently, we didn’t have the technology to keep Earle Spring alive. Until recently, the-life-and-death decisions about the senile elderly or the retarded or the institutionalized were made privately between families and medical people. Now, increasingly, in States like Massachusetts, they are made publicly and legally.
M)Clearly there are no absolutes in this case. No right to die. No right to live. We have to take into account many social as well as medical factors. How much of the resources of a society or a family should be allotted to a member who no longer recognizes it? How many sacrifices should the healthy and vital make for the terminally or permanently ill and disabled?
N)In England, where kidney dialysis machines are scarce, Earle Spring would never have remained on one. In America, one Earle Spring can decimate the energy and income of an entire family.
O)But the Spring case is a crucial, scary one that could affect all those living under that dubious sentence "incompetent" or that shaky diagnosis "senile". So it seems to me that if there is any mental activity at all, then disconnecting him from life would be a dangerous precedent, far more dangerous than letting him continue.
P)The court ruled originally in favor of taking Spring off the machine. It ruled that this is what Earle Spring would have wanted. I have no doubt that his family believes it. I have no doubt of their affection or their pain.
Q)But I remember, too, what my grandfather used to say: No one wants to live to be one hundred until you ask the man who is ninety-nine. Well, no one, including Earle Spring, wants to live to be senile. But once senile, he may well want to live. We simply have to give him the benefit of the doubt. Any doubt. [br] The story of Karen Ann Quinlan seems simple because of her brain death.
选项
答案
I
解析
题干:由于凯伦·安·昆兰的大脑已经死亡,她的故事简单多了。题干关键词是Karen Ann Quinlan,simple和brain death。文中I段提到,和这个案例比起来,凯伦·安·昆兰的故事似乎简单多了。到今天为止,昆兰在撤离医疗护理后已经活了很长时间了。而当新泽西州法院听说后,她并无意愿上法庭,因为她已经脑死亡了。与题干意思吻合,故选I。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/2811471.html
相关试题推荐
[originaltext]M:Goodafternoon,ma’am.I’mMr.Smith.Icalledyoualittlewh
[originaltext]M:Goodafternoon,ma’am.I’mMr.Smith.Icalledyoualittlewh
Oneafternoonrecently,two【B1】______friendscalledtotellmethat,well,t
Oneafternoonrecently,two【B1】______friendscalledtotellmethat,well,t
Oneafternoonrecently,two【B1】______friendscalledtotellmethat,well,t
Oneafternoonrecently,two【B1】______friendscalledtotellmethat,well,t
Oneafternoonrecently,two【B1】______friendscalledtotellmethat,well,t
Averyinterestingandimportantdevelopmentinscienceisadevicecalledl
Averyinterestingandimportantdevelopmentinscienceisadevicecalledl
Averyinterestingandimportantdevelopmentinscienceisadevicecalledl
随机试题
EvelynCokespent20yearsasahomecareaidehelpingtheelderlyandthes
Nearlytwo-thirdsofbusinessesintheUKwantto【C1】______staffwithforeign
[originaltext]M:Mrs.Hudson,anewresearchshowsthatevenjustfiveminutes
国家建筑标准设计图集16G101-1中关于混凝土保护层厚度,下列说法正确的有(
全陪是______的代表,对团队的旅游活动负有______,在整个旅游活动中起_
开展合作学习,教师需要做好哪几方面的准备?
善于治疗外感风寒、头痛鼻塞、鼻渊的药组是()A.荆芥、防风 B.麻黄、桂
孕妇,32岁,在家阴道有液体流出,无腹痛,到医院医生诊断为胎膜早破,孕妇下床小便
大伟购买了一辆纯电动汽车,原价为10万元,除去折扣和国家专项补贴后实际支付8万元
属于左心衰的典型表现是( )。A.下肢水肿 B.夜间阵发性呼吸困难 C.眼
最新回复
(
0
)