Despite winning several prestigious literary awards of the day, when it firs

游客2025-02-19 30

问题 Despite winning several prestigious literary awards of the day, when it first appeared, Alice Walker’s The Color of Purple generated critical unease over puzzling aspects of its compositions. In what, as one reviewer put it, was “clearly intended to be a realistic novel,” many reviewers perceived violations of the conventions of the realistic novel form, pointing out variously that late in the book, the narrator protagonist Celie and her friends are propelled toward a happy ending with more velocity than credibility, that the letters from Nettie to her sister Celie intrude into the middle of the main action with little motivation or warrant, and that the device of Celie’s letters to God is especially unrealistic inasmuch as it forgoes the concretizing details that traditionally have given the epistolary novel (that is, a novel composed of letters) its peculiar verisimilitude: the ruses to enable mailing letters, the cache, and especially the letters received in return.
Indeed, the violations of realistic convention are so flagrant that they might well call into question whether The Color of Purple is indeed intended to be a realistic novel, especially since there are indications that at least some of those aspects of the novel regarded by viewers as puzzling may constitute its links to modes of writing other than Anglo-European nineteenth-century realism. For example, Henry Louis Gates, Jr., has recently located the letters to God within an African American tradition deriving from slave narrative, a tradition in which the act of writing is linked to a powerful deity who “speaks” through scripture and bestows literacy as an act of grace. For Gates, the concern with finding a voice, which he sees as the defining feature of African American literature, links Celie’s letters with certain narrative aspects of Zora Neale Hurston’s 1937 novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, the acknowledged predecessor of The Color of Purple.
Gates’s paradigm suggests how misleading it may be to assume that mainstream realist criteria are appropriate for evaluating The Color of Purple. But in his preoccupation with voice as a primary element unifying both the speaking subject and the text as a whole Gates does not elucidate many of the more conventional structural features of Walker’s novel. For instance, while the letters from Nettie clearly illustrate Nettie’s acquisition of her own voice, Gates’s focus on “voice” sheds little light on the place that these letters occupy in the narrative or on why the plot takes this sudden jump into geographically and culturally removed surroundings. What is needed is an evaluative paradigm that, rather than obscuring such startling structural features (which may actually be explicitly intended to undermine traditional Anglo-European novelistic conventions), confronts them, thus illuminating the deliberately provocative ways in which The Color of Purple departs from the traditional models to which it has been compared. [br] The author of the passage suggests that Gates is most like the reviewers mentioned in the first paragraph in which of the following ways?

选项 A、He points out discrepancies between The Color of Purple and other traditional epistolary novels
B、He sees the concern with finding a voice as central to both The Color of Purple and Their Eyes Are Watching God
C、He assumes that The Color of Purple is intended to be a novel primarily in the tradition of Anglo-American nineteenth-century realism
D、He does not address many of the unsettling structural features of The Color of Purple
E、He recognizes the departure of The Color of Purple from traditional Anglo-European realistic novel conventions.

答案 E

解析本题问盖茨和第一段中reviewers之间的共同点。根据文章，共同点是都发现《紫色》的不现实，因此选项E正确。A项盖茨的评价中看不出来其他书信体小说。B项“声音”是盖茨特有的，与reviewers无关。C项reviewers没有评价《他们眼望上苍》。D项这是盖茨特有的。

转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3964015.html

相关试题推荐

随机试题

最新回复(0)

Despite winning several prestigious literary awards of the day, when it firs

Becausethesubjectmatterwassopersonal,theworkofseveralprominentmi

Becausethesubjectmatterwassopersonal,theworkofseveralprominentmi