首页
登录
职称英语
Though the free-market faithful have long preached that competition creates
Though the free-market faithful have long preached that competition creates
游客
2024-09-18
51
管理
问题
Though the free-market faithful have long preached that competition creates efficiency, as if it were a law of nature, nature itself teaches a different lesson. The seductively simple story of the virtues of competition contains some general theoretical truth, but execution is how theory dies, and we can’t let blind faith prevent us from seeing the deviling details of how it operates in practice. Unregulated competition in nature regularly delivers disaster. And ignoring nature’s lessons for our economy would have us be as dumb as trees.
Richard Dawkins tells us, "Tree trunks are standing monuments to futile competition. " No tree can afford to not compete in the height competition. However, if somehow the trees could arrange a pact of friendship to limit their heights, each tree, and the forest as a whole, could save energy. This is obviously not possible for trees, but if it were, Dawkins concludes, the " Forest of Friendship[would be]more efficient as a forest. "
Systems of self-interested agents, responding only to local incentives, can easily evolve energy-wasting, unfruitful competitions. Once a way of competing is established, it’s very difficult for individuals not to play along. If we let our economies imitate trees, and the majority of nature, in practicing unguided free competition, the results will often be suboptimal, for each and for all. Worse, we will miss the main benefit of being human, which is to use reason to coordinate better outcomes.
Enormous ill-suited "monuments to futile competition" exist at the heart of our health-care system. A 2008 study found that pharmaceutical companies spend 24% of their revenue on marketing and promotion(versus 13% on research and development). Drug prescription decisions should be based on objective medical criteria, and data on performance and side effects is publicly available. So why on earth would it make sense for pharmaceutical companies to spend so much on the armies of sales reps that visit doctors with such relentless regularity? The local logic at work is that no individual company can risk not playing the game.
Actually the lack of some cross-agent coordination prevents "the market" from increasing efficiencies in our unintelligently evolved U. S. health-care system. Competition’s benefits are created by constraints. Creative responses to designed and guided limits can work better than "natural constraints".
Free competition does not magically lead to the best outcome in nature. Nor does it in economics. The magic of markets isn’t like the magic of science: it much more resembles stage magic, where the effect is achieved by misdirection. A selective spotlight story focuses our attention, on the one hand, on the benefits of unbridled competition, but draws attention away from the other, invisible hand, as it’s busy externalizing costs or in other ways causing harm. This oversimplifying and oversold story has outlived its fitness. Our choice is either to be as dumb as trees, or to guide competition for better outcomes. [br] Which of the following can serve as the title of the passage?
选项
A、What Competition in Nature Tells about Markets.
B、Futileness of Free Competition in the Market.
C、From the Law of Nature to the Magic of Markets.
D、Questioning the Magic of Free Competition.
答案
A
解析
主旨题。文章开篇便点出主题,将自然界的竞争与经济社会规律建立联系。随后在第二段中引用专家的观点对自然界中竞争的作用进行论述,并从第三段开始转向对经济世界中竞争的作用进行论述,最后进行总结。可见,作者是用自然界的竞争来影射经济和市场规律,故[A]为答案。作者并没有对自由竞争在市场中的作用予以全盘否定,[B]的说法过于绝对,故排除;[C]“从自然规律到市场魔法”过于笼统,故排除;[D]“质疑自由竞争的魔力”不能完整涵盖全文内容,也不是最佳答案,故排除。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3763937.html
相关试题推荐
Theoutbreakwasthoughttohavebeenstarted[originaltext]OfficialsinGer
Whatistalkedaboutinthebeginningofthepassage?[originaltext]Although
Inthesentence"Three-quartersofrespondentsthoughtitimportanttocomparet
Hisdecisionismadetooquicklyandwithoutenoughthought,soitisa(n)______
Althoughourbosshadbeensounkindtous,weheapedcoalsoffireonhis______
______dullhemaybe,heiscertainlyaverysuccessfultopexecutive.A、Although
AlthoughIspoketoheraboutthematterseveraltimes,shetooklittle______of
Thoughtheyoungladywasveryprettyandgracious,shewasnone______happierfo
Althoughhehasbecomerich,heisstillvery______ofhismoney.A、economiCB、thr
Hisdecisionismadetooquicklyandwithoutenoughthought,soitisa(n)_____
随机试题
【B1】[br]【B6】A、whatB、howC、whereAabout是介词,后面要用名次或动名词作宾语,而whattodo是一个名词结构,wh
[originaltext]W:Dr.Carter’sOffice.M:Yes,I’dliketomakeanappointmentt
TheenormouslossoflifeontheTitanicwasprimarilycausedbyinadequateequi
平衡水池应设与游泳池相连接的连通管,连通管可与回水管合并设置,平衡水池底内表面宜
有一天,甲、乙、丙、丁、戊五个外国商人坐在一起聊天。甲说:“我们五个人中有一个人
患者男,30岁。右髋部撞击伤后疼痛,活动不能2小时。查体:患肢呈外展、外旋和屈曲
绿色营销以()为物质保证。A:绿色观念 B:绿色消费 C:绿色法制 D:绿
患者男性,30岁,确诊哮喘入院治疗3周,经正规治疗病情缓解,仅偶有胸闷,出院时医
在下列医德情感的描述中,错误的是A.医德情感是建立在医学科学基础上的急患者所急、
在物业管理活动中,业主享有的权利包括()。A、提议召开业主大会会议 B、执行业
最新回复
(
0
)