首页
登录
职称英语
There is, writes Daniele Fanelli in a recent issue of Nature, something rott
There is, writes Daniele Fanelli in a recent issue of Nature, something rott
游客
2024-04-08
50
管理
问题
There is, writes Daniele Fanelli in a recent issue of Nature, something rotten in the state of scientific research—an epidemic of false, biased, and falsified findings where "only the most egregious cases of misconduct are discovered and punished. "Fanelli is a leading thinker in an increasingly alarming field of scientific research: one that seeks to find out why it is that so many scientific researches turn out to be wrong.
For a long time the focus has either been on industry funding as a source of bias, particularly in drug research, or on those who deliberately commit fraud, such as the spectacular case of Diederik Stapel, a Dutch social psychologist who was found to have fabricated at least 55 research papers over 20 years. But an increasing number of studies have shown that flawed research is a much wider phenomenon, especially in the biomedical sciences. Indeed, the investigation into Stapel also blamed a "sloppy" research culture that often ignored inconvenient data and misunderstood important statistical methods.
"There’s little question that the scientific literature is awash (充斥着) in false findings—findings that if you try to replicate you’ll probably never succeed or at least find them to be different from what was initially said," says Fanelli. " But people don’t appreciate that this is not because scientists are manipulating these results, consciously or unconsciously; it’s largely because we have a system that favors statistical flukes (侥幸) instead of replicable findings. "
This is why, he says, we need to extend the idea of academic misconduct (currently limited to fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism) to "distorted reporting"—the failure to communicate all the information someone would need to validate your findings. Right now, he says, we’re missing all the "unconscious biases , the systemic biases, the practices, mistakes, and problems that hardly ever count as cheating" , even though they have a very important—and probably the largest—effect on creating technically false results in the literature.
One particularly challenging bias is that academic journals tend to publish only positive results. As Isabelle Boutron, a professor of epidemiology at Rene Descartes University in Paris, points out, studies have shown that peer reviewers are influenced by trial results; one study showed that they not only favored a paper showing a positive effect over a near-identical paper showing no effect, they also gave the positive paper higher scores for its scientific methods. And Boutron has herself found extensive evidence of scientists spinning their findings to claim benefits that their actual results didn’t quite support.
"We need a major cultural change," says Fanelli. "But when you think that, even 20 years ago, these issues were practically never discussed, I think we’re making considerable progress. " [br] According to the passage, which of the following statements is true?
选项
A、Academic misconduct is limited on industry funding and academic fraud.
B、Conscious manipulation of scientists is to blame for the increasingly false findings.
C、Positive research findings won’t bring about fame for scientists.
D、Fanelli still feels confident about the prospect.
答案
D
解析
细节题。文章最后法内利坦青虽然我们需要文化大改革,但是总体而言进步很大,说明他对前景还是很乐观的。
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3546809.html
相关试题推荐
[originaltext]Ourenvironmentisbeingpollutedfasterthannatureandman’
[originaltext]Ourenvironmentisbeingpollutedfasterthannatureandman’
[originaltext]Ourenvironmentisbeingpollutedfasterthannatureandman’
[originaltext]W:Mybikewasstolenrecently.Isitpossibletolendmeyoursf
[originaltext]W:Mybikewasstolenrecently.Isitpossibletolendmeyoursf
[originaltext]W:Mybikewasstolenrecently.Isitpossibletolendmeyoursf
[originaltext]Inrecentyears,manyAmericansofbothsexesandvariousage
[originaltext]Inrecentyears,manyAmericansofbothsexesandvariousage
[originaltext]Recentlyafive-yearstudywasconductedbytheCenterforCh
[originaltext]Recentlyafive-yearstudywasconductedbytheCenterforCh
随机试题
UsingMindMapstoDevelopOurWritingBesidesreadingm
SouthAfricaSafariTopFiveNationalParksandGameReserves[A]
Whenapersonfallsasleep,allactivitydecreasesandthemusclesrelax.Th
甲、乙、丙三人各乘一架直升飞机,甲看到楼房匀速上升,乙看到甲匀速上升,丙看到乙匀
属于流化干燥技术的是A.真空干燥 B.冷冻干燥 C.沸腾干燥 D.
国民资产负债统计中存货按照统一的( )进行估价。A.购进价格 B.固定价格
建设单位应当将大型的人员密集场所和其他特殊建筑工程的消防设计文件报送公安机关消防
在进行资产减值测试时,下列表述正确的有( )。A.资产预计的未来现金流量包括与资
企业规划定位是在规划分析基础上,明确在企业总体战略指导下的具体方针和思路,凝练成
关于正常妊娠期肝功能变化,下列说法错误的是A.由于血液稀释,血清总蛋白降低 B
最新回复
(
0
)