首页
登录
职称英语
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world
游客
2023-08-06
36
管理
问题
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world forever? Or is it already bumping into limits? In his 2011 book The Beginning of Infinity physicist David Deutsch made the case for boundlessness. When I asked him about consciousness, he replied: "I think nothing worth understanding will always remain a mystery. And consciousness seems apparently worth understanding. "
At a meeting I just attended in Switzerland, "The Mystery of Human Consciousness," another famous British physicist, Martin Rees, challenged Deutsch’s optimism. In that essay Rees calls The Beginning of Infinity "provocative and excellent" but disputes Deutsch’s central claim that science is boundless. Science "will hit the buffers (缓冲区) at some point," Rees warns.
There are two reasons why this might happen. The optimistic one is that we clean up and understand certain areas (such as atomic physics) to the point that there’s no more to say. A second, more worrying possibility is that we’ll reach the limits of what our brains can grasp. There might be concepts, crucial to a full understanding of physical reality. Efforts to understand very complex systems, such as our own brains, might well be the first to hit such limits.
Perhaps complex collectives of atoms, whether brains or electronic machines, can never know all there is to know about themselves.
The riddle of consciousness is a synecdoche for the riddle of humanity. What we, really? For most of our history, religion has given us the answer. Most modern scientists reject these religious explanations, but they cannot agree on an alternative. They have proposed a bewildering variety of answers to the question of what we really are.
Science will never resolve these disagreements and converge on a single, true theory of what we are, for two reasons. One is that we will never have a "consciousness meter," an objective means of measuring consciousness in non-human things. The other is that we are too varying, too creative, to be captured by a single theory. Science itself keeps transforming us. with technologies as diverse as brain implants, genetic therapy and ideas as diverse as queer theory and integrated information theory. To be human means to be a work in progress.
Deutsch’s claim that science is infinite also has a contradiction at its core. He wants science to solve the deepest mysteries, like consciousness, and yet to have more mysteries to solve, forever. That is a radical assertion about the structure of nature, which to my mind reflects wishful thinking rather than hardheaded realism.
Deutsch is both wrong and right. He is wrong that science can solve every mystery, and especially consciousness. We will never understand, once and for all, who we are. But Deutsch is right that science is potentially infinite, if infinite means never-ending. It is precisely because we can never achieve total self-knowledge that we will keep seeking it forever. [br] What docs the author think of Deutsch’s point of view?
选项
A、Partially acceptable.
B、Completely irrational.
C、Somewhat groundless.
D、Quite encouraging.
答案
A
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://tihaiku.com/zcyy/2901899.html
相关试题推荐
[originaltext]SpeakingattheBritishScienceFestivalonTuesday,ProfKel
[originaltext]SpeakingattheBritishScienceFestivalonTuesday,ProfKel
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
TheBirthofScientificEnglishA)Worldscienceisdominate
HowCanGirlsWininMathandScience?A)Mathisacumulat
HowCanGirlsWininMathandScience?A)Mathisacumulat
随机试题
[img]2018m9x/ct_ehbm_ehbreadf_0195_201809[/img][br]Whichorganizationisplann
A.0.02 B.0.07 C.0.12 D.0.17
(2011年)下列各课税要素,与纳税期限的选择密切相关的是( )。A.纳税人
混凝土抗折强度试验,若3个试件中有1个折断面位于两个集中荷载之外,则混凝土抗折强
A.钙通道拮抗剂 B.β受体阻滞剂 C.血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂 D.洋地黄
某大型商务楼位于市中心十字路口,32层,层高3m,地下2层,地上1~7层是商业用
关于社会工作价值观操作原则的说法,正确的有()。A:社会工作者不应与服务对象分享
仲裁庭调解达成协议的,调解书自()即发生法律效益。A.仲裁庭制作完成后 B.当
下列哪种方法最有助于区别血尿与血红蛋白尿A.观察血尿颜色 B.做尿胆原测验
能引起肾病综合征的疾病是A、隐匿性肾炎 B、间质性肾炎 C、急性肾盂肾炎
最新回复
(
0
)