首页
登录
职称英语
Nowhere is this more true than in the awarding of prizes. Because prizes car
Nowhere is this more true than in the awarding of prizes. Because prizes car
游客
2023-12-12
117
管理
问题
Nowhere is this more true than in the awarding of prizes. Because prizes carry the approval of an institution, we expect them to be somehow more authoritative than ordinary reviews. But even the winners of the most prestigious awards are chosen by individuals, each with his or her own particular tastes, and the high stakes involved can make those choices even more capricious. Recently, I was explaining to a mathematician friend how I had screened the scores of nonfiction books that were candidates for the short list of a national literary prize I participate in judging. "If by Page 100 the author hasn’t managed to get me interested in the topic, I eliminate it," I said. "Surely there are objective criteria?" he replied, sounding a bit offended. Well, not really; a tedious volume full of useful information may have its merits, but not enough to make me champion it as one of the five best books of the year. And determining whether a work is boring or enthralling can be only a subjective decision.
选项
答案
在奖项颁发这个问题上,这一点表现得最为透彻。由于奖项代表某个机构的认可,我们期望它们比一般的评论更具有权威性。但即便是最具权威性的奖项,其获得者也是由一个个评委选出的,每个评委都有各自的鉴赏标准,而且奖项涉及的利害关系越大,选择就越不可信。最近我参与评选一个非小说类作品的国家级文学奖,我向一个数学家朋友解释我是怎样打分的:“如果读到第100页作者还没能让我对他的主题感兴趣,我就将其排除在外。”“客观的标准肯定是有的,不是吗?”他回答道,听起来有点不满。依我看,客观标准不大会有。一部乏味的但充满有用信息的作品也许有它的价值,但不足以让我选它为本年度最佳五部作品之一。决定一本书到底是枯燥乏味还是充满吸引力只能是一种主观判断。
解析
转载请注明原文地址:http://tihaiku.com/zcyy/3266365.html
相关试题推荐
DaydreamingⅠ.Daydreamingcanbeharmfulbecauseitwascon
DaydreamingⅠ.Daydreamingcanbeharmfulbecauseitwascon
DaydreamingⅠ.Daydreamingcanbeharmfulbecauseitwascon
DaydreamingⅠ.Daydreamingcanbeharmfulbecauseitwascon
GovernmentofficialsorderedaplantinJapantohaltproductionbecause______.
GovernmentofficialsorderedaplantinJapantohaltproductionbecause______.
Why,youmaywonder,shouldspidersbeourfriends?Becausetheyprotectso
Why,youmaywonder,shouldspidersbeourfriends?Becausetheyprotectso
Why,youmaywonder,shouldspidersbeourfriends?Becausetheyprotectso
Why,youmaywonder,shouldspidersbeourfriends?Becausetheyprotectso
随机试题
Dearsir,ThankyouforyourletteronMarch15.Weknowthatyouwanttoor
[originaltext]BarbaraSandersisawifeandthemotheroftwochildren,age
教育学发展中逐渐形成了不同的理论流派。其中杜威倡导的是()。A.实用主义教育学
党对富农在不同时期实行不同的政策,体现的哲学道理是()。 A.分清主要矛盾和次
根据《公司法》的规定,自然人或者法人均可投资设立一人有限责任公司。下列关于一人有
岩质岸坡多出现在峡谷和丘陵水库,其破坏形式以下列哪项为主()A.塌岸 B.滑坡
下列各项中,不属卫生行政处罚的是( )。A.警告 B.停止损害 C.罚款
导致各种疟疾潜伏期长短不一的最主要原因是A、人体免疫力的差异B、疟原虫的种类和
设定货物申请人的资格能力要素和标准的依据不包括()A.拟采购货物的技术、经济及
环保疏浚污染土依据污染物类型和影响途径共分为()。A.三类 B.四类 C.
最新回复
(
0
)